Well, I've always felt the 2.23 score for Bud Light Platinum was at least a point too high. All kidding aside, I'll throw in Great Notion's Double Stack as a candidate. It's actually a pretty decent beer, don't get me wrong (especially for an adjunct stout that sees no barrel aging), but I think its BA score is greatly over inflated. I'm always stunned by some of the things folks are willing to trade for it in the trading forums (especially as the beer has become increasingly easy to obtain, now that GN has opened it's production brewery over on the West side of town). That being said, I think I'm starting to see a trend here. DS is another very sweet stout (lot of chocolate and maple syrup flavor), that seems to hit a lot of consumer's sweet tooth just right. The level of sweetness is actually the beer's biggest detraction, IMHO.