WLP833 vs. S-23 in a Traditional Bock

Discussion in 'Homebrewing' started by hopsandmalt, Dec 10, 2012.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. hopsandmalt

    hopsandmalt Initiate (0) Dec 14, 2006 Michigan

    I'm brewing a traditional bock next and the recipe I have calls for WLP833 German bock lager yeast. I really don't feel like making a huge starter. Am I going to loose anything by subbing in a few packets of S-23? Here is the recipe:

    10 gal. O.G. 1.072

    20# Munich
    5# Pilsner
    1# Crystal 120
    .5# Melanoidin
    .5# Special B

    1.15oz. Nugget 60 Min.

    Single infusion mash 60 min. @155F

    Ferment 2 weeks @ 50F
    Lager 6 weeks @ 35F
  2. BigAB

    BigAB Initiate (0) Aug 4, 2008 Iowa

    I have never used S-23. I've heard, however, that it may benefit from slightly warmer temps as some people claim a number of not-so-great byproducts.

    S-23 would make a very different beer than WLP833 (the Ayinger yeast strain, very distinctive IMO). I love the this strain, and though the S-23 could probably make a decent beer, it would not be the same as what WLP833 would produce.
  3. OldSock

    OldSock Defender (646) Apr 3, 2005 District of Columbia

    I've used both strains, and I really like the WLP833. S23 will make a fine beer, but it is a bit fruitier, and it doesn't accentuate the maltiness quite as much. Maybe a blend of the two, just pitch a small starter of the White Labs vial along with a pack of S23 to get your cell count where it need to be?

    As an aside, I also really like Simpsons Extra Dark Crystal in my strong bocks. I’ve got one lagering now (WLP833 fermented) that spend a few in a five gallon malt whisky barrel. It adds a more complex dark fruit than Special B, and just a hint of coffee. Really looking forward to that one!

    Good luck either way.
  4. Pegli

    Pegli Initiate (0) Aug 30, 2006 Rhode Island

    If you're going to through the all effort to make 10 gallons of lager, take the extra 1/2 hour a few days prior and make a starter. WLP833 is my favorite all-time lager yeast which makes spectacular bocks and doppelbocks.
  5. hopsandmalt

    hopsandmalt Initiate (0) Dec 14, 2006 Michigan

    Yeah I was thinking about mixing the two strains just to up my cell count or possibly using one strain in one carboy and the other in the second.

    So you suggest swapping out the Special B for Simpsons extra dark crystal pound for pound?

    Also do you know it's lovibond rating? How dark is "Extra dark"?
  6. hopsandmalt

    hopsandmalt Initiate (0) Dec 14, 2006 Michigan

    Making one starter wouldn't be a problem, I make a starter for every beer I make. However making two starters (one for each carboy) and decanting/stepping them up multiple times when I only have one 2000ml flask, one stir plate and limited refrigeration space is a problem.
  7. premierpro

    premierpro Disciple (381) Mar 21, 2009 Michigan

    Use the WLP833. Don't scrimp on the yeast for this beer.
    Pegli likes this.
  8. OldSock

    OldSock Defender (646) Apr 3, 2005 District of Columbia

    I think doing a split batch sounds like a fun idea, see for yourself the difference the lager yeast can make. In the future you could always do a 5 gallon batch of dunkel to produce enough yeast for your bigger batches of bock.

    The Simpsons Extra Dark is ~155 L. I’d probably swap it out pound for pound for the Special B and C120, but I don’t mind a deep leathery colored bock. I stole the idea from The Livery (they use it in their Wheat Trippelbock).
  9. pweis909

    pweis909 Meyvn (1,314) Aug 13, 2005 Wisconsin

    I have used S-23 and found it to make a slightly fruity lager. Not excessively so, but still detectably so. It does seem to prefer warmer lager temps, which may be the cause of the fruitiness.I've used S-23, S-W34/70, and liquid yeasts in pilsners. They all made drinkable beers, but the liquid was best, but I was also fond of S-W34/70. If you can get your hands on Saflager it, I think you will find it a more suitable dry yeast than S-23, at least for a bock.

  10. Patrick

    Patrick Initiate (0) Aug 13, 2007 Massachusetts

    I've used S-23 in a Baltic Porter and it was a bit too fruity for my tastes. Still a fine beer, but I don't dig the fruitiness of this beer.
  11. pweis909

    pweis909 Meyvn (1,314) Aug 13, 2005 Wisconsin

  12. mikehartigan

    mikehartigan Aspirant (290) Apr 9, 2007 Illinois

    Since you're curious, this is an ideal way to answer your own question. Both will likely make excellent beers, so there's no real risk and, indeed, you may even decide that you prefer S-23 in a Bock or, perhaps, get an idea of a style in which it might be better suited. In the end, you'll know more than you know now. And you'll have one more tool in your arsenal.
    hopsandmalt likes this.
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  • About Us

    Your go-to website for beer (since 1996), publishers of BeerAdvocate magazine (since 2006) and hosts of world-class beer events (since 2003). Respect Beer.
  • BeerAdvocate Microbrew Invitational

    Join us June 2-3, 2017 in Boston, Mass. for beer, cider, mead, kombucha and sake from over 70 small producers.

    Learn More
  • Subscribe to BeerAdvocate Magazine

    Support uncompromising beer advocacy and award-winning, independent journalism with a print subscription to BeerAdvocate magazine.