If you had to pick 10...

In no particular order:

Duvel
Cantillon St Lamvinus
3F Golden Blend
Funk Metal
Black Albert
Enjoy By 12-21
Andechser Doppelbock
Ayinger Ur-Weisse
Westvleteren 12
Ayinger Octoberfest

 

No order:
GumballHead
Zombie Dust
Pliny
Pure Hoppiness
Sculpin
Hacker Pschorr Weisse
Karl Strauss Peanut Butter Cup Porter
The Pupil
The Apprentice
Rogue Chocolate Stout

#1 want to try...Heady

 

I've only been drinking beer for like a year and a half so my experience probably isn't as diverse as most of you, but here it goes.

Weihenstephaner Hefeweizen
St Bernadus ABT 12
Ommegang Three Philosophers
La Trappe Quadrupel
Dogfish Head Punkin Ale
Westmalle Tripel
Sam Adams Old Fezewig
Tripel Karmeliet
Utopias

 

Losing steam here so not enough energy to really think deeply about this...but your list is pretty nice. I've had most of those and hard to argue with many there. I'd swap Coffee for Cherry Rye and maybe King Henry for Church; prob a Loon for the Consecration.

Let's be real, if you could only drink your 10 beers for the rest of your life I don't think that would be a problem for most of us. You are missing a saison there though.

 

CW 15
CW 16
CW PM(not infected) And regular Bourbon stout
NG IIPA
FFF ZD
FFF PF
KBS
FBS
Backwoods Bastard
Sucks
mmm so many more
Edit; forgot about BCBS. Coffee and regular are on there for sure

 

In no particular order:
Pliny
Parabola
Prairie Hop
Imperial Biscotti Break
Sucks
Black Butte 25th
Pannepot
Logsdon Oak Aged Seizon Bretta
Bear Republic Tartare
Enjoy By

 

1998 JW Lees Harvest Ale
2008 World Wide Stout
Bravo Brown
Cherry Rye
Sucaba
Fruet
Matt
2012 120 Minute IPA
Bois
Parabola

 

Tried to give myself some variety but so much is missing, if this was a real decision it would take me a solid week of contemplation to decide.
BCBCS
White Oak Jai Alai
Founders Backwoods Bastard
Matilda
Hunahpu
Heady
Allagash Curieux
Maiden Fields
PBR
Sucaba

 

Two Hearted
BA Expedition
Cup of Joe
HotD Adam
Cantillon Classic Gueuze
Founders Cream of the Rock
Jolly Pumpkin LaRoja
Anchor Steam
Backwoods Bastard
Brown Shugga

Maybe not the 10 best but certainly the 10 I'd live off of. 10 best would have to make room for BCBVS.

 

Not in order....

Parabola
KBS
Abyss
BCBS
Cantillon Classic Gueuze
Rodenbach Vintage
Deschutes Green Monster
The Dissident (2010)
Abbey Saint Bon Chien (2007)
(open spot for Beatification, Fou Foune, or Oude tart... in cellar, yet to try)

I should mention (brag) that I literally have had the first 4 to drink TONIGHT (2011 or 2012 vintage of each), which equals very drunk.

 

love the old fezziwig choice...personally think that if old fezziwig and cream stout were bottled under the name of stone or FFF, people would respect these brews much more

 

Rare
BCBS
Heady
Imperial Biscotti Break
Flower Power
Double Sunshine
Rochefort 10
FBS
Parabola
Sucaba

 

I'm sure this will fluctuate a lot for me over time and according to certain moments. I find the right beer with the right setting can really put things over the top sometimes.

No particular order:
Heady
Parabola
BCBS Coffee
Supplication
Tree House Curiosity #4
Cantillon St. Lamnivus
KBS
Hill Farmstead E.
Duck Duck Gooze
Almanac Farmer's Reserve #2

 

If I'm restricted to 10 beers I would have to choose those I could drink all day long without tiring of them.No "show ponies" therefore.
No problem.It was like that when I began drinking and we were all happy with what we had.Well made good ordinary everyday stuff which improved with every pint as we went along.Thankfully I can still get beer like them so come Armageddon I'm well placed.

 

I'd try to hit at least one from all my favorite styles:

Heady Topper
Ten FIDY
Founders Breakfast Stout
Three Philosophers
La Fin du Monde
Ommegang (dubbel)
Sierra Nevada Bigfoot
Full Sail Session
Dogfish Head Positive Contact
Schneider Weisse Unser Tap 6

 

Right now, something like:

Worthington's White Shield
Timothy Taylor's Landlord
Adnams' Southwold Bitter
Fuller's 1845
Augustiner Helles
Schlenkerla Märzen
Budvar Dark
Tripel Karmeliet
Guinness Foreign Extra
Schneider Weisse Original

 

I would go with 10 different styles:
Southern Tier- Choklat
Weihenstephaner- Vitus
Pretty Things- Baby Tree
Ommegang- Hennepin
Furthermore Beer- Fatty Boombalatty
Three Floyds- Zombie Dust
New Belgium- Trippel Belgian style ale
Samuel Smith's- Organic Chocolate Stout
Hoegaarden- Original White ale
Saranac- Caramel porter

 

Stuff I do not have to trade for, or drive more than 30min to get:
Sam Adams Boston Lager
Sam Adams Double Agent IPL
Jack's Abby Hoponious Union
Jacky's abby Jabby Brau
Ithaca Flower Power
Marshall Warf Ace Hole
Harpoon IPA
Oxbow farmhouse Pale
Oxbow Oxtoberfest
Oxbow Funkhaus IPA

Thats all I would ever need.

 

I'm sensing a trend. The liquor store near me will soon have dirtwolf on tap. I will be filling many growlers that week.

 

In no particular order

Founders KBS
Goose Island Bourbon County Coffee Stout
Heady Topper
Lawson's Double Sunshine
Firestone Walker Parabola
Founders Breakfast Stout
Pliny the Elder
Tree House Julius
Hill Farmstead Everett
Hill Farmstead Abner