Trade Value Thread (TVT) Quarter 4 2018

Depends on dawg beers. Boozy with need 2+. Most others would be around 4+

 

Planning on putting together an offer when the bourbon and Okie single barrels are released in January. Thank you for the info!

 

I don't trade often, and am certainly not up to date on trade values, so any information is appreciated...

I have some Nutsmasher and Maple Nutsmasher for trade. I recently saw a regular plus a maple for FO get done. What else could be in play? BADL? ADWTD? Abraxas? Variants on any of these? Just trying to get a general idea. Thanks!

 

I agree, but the problem with FO4 is most guys who still have some to trade want wayyy more then it's worth now that PC is out. I mean think about it do you think FO for PC is an even trade?

 

I don't know much about Nutsmasher, but if it took both variants to get FO4 then you might be able to get regular Abraxas with one of them. BADL is way out of range. ADTWD depends on which variant. The "regular" cognac 750 mL bottle hasn't been released in several years AFAIK so that one is somewhere just under BADL level, but maybe one of the 375 mL bottles could be attainable with those. Probably not the Double Oaked though.

 

Not a lot of demand for those bottles. I would say no to BADL. ADWTD may be possible. Regular Abraxas is pretty easy to obtain. Post it up and see what happens.

 

Thanks guys! That's super helpful!

 

People say great things about the Transient BA stouts (Canuckley, Kentuckley, Ruckley) and they trade only a little higher than FOb4.

 

Will Trillium BA Affogato get me close to Maman?

 

Thank you...have you had Maman?

How’s it compare to Rare 15?

 

What he said...i’d put Maman up against any non-adjunct BA stout any day as well. Maman 15 is still the greatest BA Stout I’ve ever had.

 

Trying to get a bottle of Coconut Medianoche do you think a Paisley Cave bottle is a fair trade?

 

Just drank a maman 17 and for me it had a lot of characteristics of assassin. Both were viscous and had the barrel present. Both had the cherry ending as well. I would rate maman a tad bit higher just because it has a better mouth feel.

 

Maman 18 - You may need a solid plus with it. Reg affogato

Maman 17 - (2) BA affogatos with a small plus.

 

Just a prefix, sorry if I am way off but I haven't done any beer trade for US beers in my life only around the european side of things.

I didn't see to much discussion about it but wanted to ask how close is a bottle magnum bottle of Cantillon Gueze 2016 or 2015 to the likes of Assassins's, Mamans or French Vanilla Militia and such.

Edit: Grammar fixes.

 

Hey BA, currently trying to trade for bottle logic NC + FS, what would I have to add around pastry method ? I have all the horus releases minus proper, got pre releases to then newest one migration.

 

Pastry method likely gets you a NC but is probably short on FS. Most likely looking at 2 more other horus bottles to get a FS, people aren't giving them up easy. To get both in one trade, I suspect you need a bigger anchor, people holding both for a single deal are probably waiting to trade up, not trying to get bulk they could probably get another way. GL.

 

If you have immoderation and wanna trade for number crunch hit me up.