Trade Value Thread (2020)

I think PCC + Umibozu would be closer. You possibly would need a plus, but I think it adds up, especially as others have stated how much easier attainable BAA 2020 is to get.

Seems this batch of FO is being flip more or less at cost. It is tough to use it to "trade up"

I think @eppie82 hit it on the nose.

 

Anabasis b4 for Coco Noche 2020. Anyone need to add a plus or is this essentially 1:1?

 

I would think small plus on the coco noche side.

 

Thanks for the insight!

 

Does DFH BA WWS have any trade value?

Would this trade for the latest SP Jammy $4?

 

Thanks for the insight, trying to gauge the moving target of trade values as things become more attainable is tricky. Appreciate the advice!

 

Would the following (3:1) be close for getting either an '18 Assassin or Rrari Crochet:?

'18 BC Prop
'19 BC Prop
'19 BC reserve Rye

Or 5:1 for '19 Chemtrail

'18 BC Prop
'19 BC Prop
'19 BC reserve Rye
Central Waters 22
Central Waters BA Maple stout

Thanks!

 

What's the going rate for Weller FP?

 

DH Tiramisu for westly? West Ashley?

 

Disregarding secondary since I don’t know. Westly was always a Sara Cellar bottle, member bottle, then it became public this year at 1 pp/$30. West Ashley is $25 and usually 3 pp public. Given the “limited” release of DBT, 1000 bottles, I could see 1:1+ for Westly and 1:2+ for West Ashley. I could be totally off too. Those in the secondary know may have better input.

 

Don't think Westly or West Ashley need a plus, should be 1:1 or 1:2 right now. Although, I expect DB Tiramisu to drop in value once the reviews come in (like all Trill stouts), so may not be able to pull a Westly later on.

 

I think one thing to keep in mind is location overlap with your FT and ISO, specifically talking about Rrari, but to a degree Assassin too. Unless someone from outside Chicagoland is looking for your ISO, the beers you listed most of us can go out and get to-go (any beers on your BC list) from GI themselves in a lot of cases. I just did a $4$ trade last month with basically any of those for an assortment of NE IPAs. I even offered Rare ‘15 since I could’ve grabbed that to-go too. The other thing is, and this is my personal opinion, none of those bottles are going to be ‘anchor’ enough to separate someone from Rrari.

But I’ve been wrong before! Good luck.

 

This really applies to two folks on this page, so here you go.

I traded a Rrari Crochet for a Weller Full Proof single barrel pick. I felt this was really fair for both parties, as we both paid about $50-60 for our bottles, and secondary value is about the same too. The Rrari is technically a more rare item, but I’ve got more dark lord than I know what to do with and don’t particularly like strawberry.

Regarding what Eppie82 said, I think the anchor principle applies on trading a lot of little bottles (value not ounces) for one medium/large bottle. It’s hard to part with a bigger bottle unless you are getting A LOT of little stuff. But, maybe someone out there doesn’t like strawberry.

 

Assasin 18 is the "least valuable" assassin so I think that you would be good on it for that 3:1. Rrari is closer to chemtrail, I don't think that 5:1 would close for either. You'd need a better anchor bottle for that trade

~300

DB Tiramisu is all over the place right now, you might be able to get 2 west ashleys for it or 1+ for westly

 

What’s the going rate/rough estimate on an Amalgam Muted Horn? I can’t really find much information on it. Am I wrong when I say it’s not anywhere close to a Hibiki 12?

 

I wouldn’t normally think so but with SP so much easier to get during Covid it may be possible

 

I don't think this has any trade value.

You might be better off looking for a proxy after buying it online and sending some thank your beers from local breweries

 

Yeah, my inclination was no but given the amount of Jammy produced (395 left right now), cost for cost crossed my mind but proxy / thank you beers is probably the way to go. Thanks all.

 

Wws does see distribution across states even if it's limited. .. Was part of the main reason I felt it was 0 value

 

What’s Angry Chair Adjunct Trail (non-BA) go for? Wondering where to start.