Trade Value Thread (Q3 2021)

Would two 2021 VSOJ cans get close to a 375ml bottle of vanilla assassin?

 

I think that’s about halfway there.

 

That's being generous. You might be able to get one for 4 VSOJ cans, but looking more like 6-7 cans to be honest. VBA is probably one of the best beers I've had though, so definitely think it's worth trying to land one.

 

Yeah, your assessment might be more accurate than mine — the main message I intended to convey was “this isn’t very close” so I was less concerned with whether 1 or 2 might make it closer.

 

In terms of Zenne y Frontera, what, if any, would a batch 1 Duck Duck Gooze land? And what about Cantillon?

 

You don't see a lot of b1 DDG for trade. Based on what is posted elsewhere DDG b1 is short of Zenne b1 and probably short of b2 Zenne (solera), but could probably land 2-3 of the later blends. Maybe with the right trader and the rarity of b1 DDG you can get lucky and land a Zenne b2, but b2 seems to be getting harder to find.

As far as Cantillon DDG b1 could probably go 1:1 with beers like Lambic d'Aunis, Magic lambic, Drogone, or older vintage LPK. Depending on the trader maybe 1:1 with Blabaer. Or depending on the bottle and vintage, multiple of St. Lam, Fou, Nath, GcB.

Hope that helps!!

 

Is there a general order of Weldwerks Medianoche variants? I know Starry Noche trades super high, but dont know much about the other ones. Are they all semi-interchangeable?

 

Anything with Coconut seems to trade higher. Medianoche Reserve '21, and Coconut Medianoche trade higher (but not as high as Starry). Everything else seems to trade fairly the same which is pretty obtainable.

Would also say that Coconut Coffee Medianoche honestly drinks amazing, personally think it should trade as high as Reserve or Coconut Medianoche, but for some reason that one doesn't get the hype.

 

Thanks - super helpful. Seems like the rest trade around 50-75ish. Is that right?

 

Yep, maybe 50-85ish, depending on the bottle.

 

There's also a timing component here as well - it seems like older batches retain their value moreso than newer ones - look at PBC Medianoche.

 

Where's AC barrel aged vanilla Popinski in relation to latest Maman?

 

$4$ I think you're close with a small plus....rarity/secondary wise you're short by a good margin. Popinski isn't nearly as highly sought after as other AC, and even though this one has two really highly desired adjuncts (nills and rye), I think you'd need to add another similar bottle.

 

My knowledge of fair stout trades far exceeds my knowledge of Old Money sours, so would love some impressions on the value of the new batch of Cable Car (OG, not the Kriek).

Would Henna Cinnamon Maple Vanilla, Boiler Basil Haden Killa or BAA 21 come close?

 

Where is the value for perennial 10th anniversary at?

Thanks

 

I posted a trade
FT CCK
ISO Starry b2

Am I short on my end?

 

Seems to be very on par with generational and continuance. Or ~200

 

I don’t necessarily think you’re short. BA trade forums sometimes move slowly. If you’re not in a huge hurry I would give it a few days.
Then think about adding a + or posting on another venue.

 

Ok what's Perennial 10 Anny going for? 1.5 VRU? Is generational + BA Sump + Blended 17 way too much? Plus on the 10th Anny side?