FT: BAA '18 || ISO: Black Magicks

I can't speak for everyone, but this is well off-base IMO. Silver BM is a solid plus (BCBS Rare) off BAA currently.

 

For what it's worth, I think your trade offer is very fair. I am partial to qty. of Black Magick since they are small format and I can drink them by myself. BAA is awesome and I would think you will get this done.

 

1:3 does seem to be asking a lot but yeah the guy above saying it's 1:1+ is off. This is probably 1:2 or 1+:3.

 

How is 1+:1 off? Silver Wax climbing in razzle prices to 180 now, while BAA can be had at 280/270. Add in the plus of a Rare 15-ish beer and you're about at that point.

All this being said, head to facebook and post that on the Voodoo Brewery Trading League, you'll have a better shot there knocking this out, IMO.

 

It is crazy to me that people cannot grasp the idea that trading is not a simple as adding up secondary values until they match. This is not the ESPN trade machine.

 

Yeah, but nobody with a BAA will take it.

 

Completely aware this isn't just an 'add them up and call it a deal' situation, but the same 'right set of eyes' applies to the BM + as it would the 3:1. Also, when you find someone willing to 3:1+, let me know. I'll happily go BIN a BAA and make that trade.

 

I think the right plus on the BAA side gets that done but who knows. Voodoo guys are always thirsty AF to trade their bottles. I would know...they often trade them to me

 

No arguments here - they do appear to be holding more often with the Silver. I've had a harder time hoarding them this go around.

 

Yeah lots of folks saying that Silver is the best BM since the BRC I bottles.

 

Hi Original Poster!

I dont do secondary values...abort trades that get into it. I dont wish to be part of that movement. So no opinion on fairness. If two parties agree, its fair to me...the only two people's who opinions matter. Anyways, Im chiming in to say or confirm (IMO) silver wax is the best since Pappy.