Anyone else have problems with a BA that cant do math?

So a few weeks ago I posted an ISO:FT looking to ship a bottle of BT for some KBS, and grinnellj responded. We spent some time dickering around, and when I was able to score 2 more bottles we decided to expand out for 2x BT in exchange for 5x KBS and 4x BCBS. At that point we discussed expanding out further (I hated the idea of sending 2 bottles + extras and getting 9 bottles + extra's back).

After some back and forth, we decide on "roughly" $100 dollars worth of beer each way (I expressed my intent to go a bit over the $ amount since the $/oz was skewed in my favor).

Well, here's the contents of the box I opened earlier this evening


I dont know if the midwest works under a different system of currency than the west coast, but I'm pretty sure this is absolutely ridiculous! The guy sent more extras than he did beers that were agreed on as part of the core trade!

Just the extra's:

In order of left to right, thats:
Weyerbacher Simcoe IPA
Founders Backwood Bastard
New Glarus Saison
Hoppin Frog DORIS
Jolly Pumpkin/Maui Brew Co Sobrehumano
Founders Curmudgeons Better Half
Founders/Blackheart Blackbeard
Terrapin/Jittery Joe's W-n-B
Shorts Key Lime Pie and Peaches and Cream
Bells Expedition Stout
Surly Furious.

About halfway through the box I was lost for words. My fiance wound up wandering over, and after seeing the look on my face as I continued to unwrap bottle after bottle, told me that my christmas is over, and that i should lower my expectations.

But seriously, if you ever get a chance to trade with grinnellj, I suggest not doing it if you live on the west coast. I want that bastard all to myself.

 

And thats what happens when I post after drinking!

EDIT: Updated initial post to reflect BCBS instead of CBS