Buffalo Nickel
Double Nickel Brewing Company

Buffalo NickelBuffalo Nickel
Rate It
Beer Geek Stats | Print Shelf Talker
Double Nickel Brewing Company
New Jersey, United States
American Imperial Stout
4.12 | pDev: 8.74%
Apr 26, 2020
Feb 13, 2016
Buffalo NickelBuffalo Nickel
Notes: None
Recent ratings and reviews. | Log in to view more ratings + sorting options.
Rated: 4.21 by odenbr12 from New Jersey

Apr 26, 2020
Rated: 4.19 by Beerjawn8 from New Jersey

Apr 11, 2020
Rated: 3.73 by Sammy from Canada (ON)

Aug 29, 2019
Rated: 4.75 by chiefz1 from New York

Aug 02, 2018
Photo of suspiciousone
Reviewed by suspiciousone from New Jersey

2.84/5  rDev -31.1%
look: 3 | smell: 2.75 | taste: 2.75 | feel: 3 | overall: 3
Not terrible but the taste of alcohol is a little overpowering. The color is a little less interesting that I would have liked. The smell of the beer is a bit bland but the feel is slightly better. Overall there are many better choices in this style.
Apr 26, 2018
Photo of Tony210
Reviewed by Tony210 from New Jersey

4.1/5  rDev -0.5%
look: 4.25 | smell: 4.25 | taste: 4 | feel: 4.25 | overall: 4
Pours very dark with a nice mocha head that fizzles out quickly. Nice chololate aroma, some molasses and brown sugar. Slightly thin mouthfeel, but not bad for 8.5% abv! Lots of bittersweet chocolate, burnt brown sugar, charred barrel, dark roast coffee. Carbonation helps out with a creamy mouthfeel. Overall I would call this the first "session BA imperial stout" I have ever tried. It is good, but I think the brewer could make this better if it were 11%. I like the beer, and bought a few to age. This was not a good idea. The first one I drank had a lot more flavor to it. This one is starting to fade, and the barrel feels more like a red wine barrel than a bourbon barrel. I would recommend drinking this beer fresh.

Bomber, 2016 vintage (fall 2016)
4 rating

Update - 5/9/21. This tastes way better after 4.5 years aging. Flavor really rounded out nicely, tastes like a BCBS. Body even got better!
Mar 28, 2018
Photo of jzeilinger
Reviewed by jzeilinger from Pennsylvania

4.1/5  rDev -0.5%
look: 4 | smell: 4 | taste: 4.25 | feel: 4 | overall: 4
A - Dark brown/black pour with thick tan colored lacing.

S - Oak, bourbon, cherry, light char, delicate spice.

T - Spicy bourbon and char, no more, no less.

M - Medium body with with some lip smacking stickiness.

O -
Jan 15, 2018
Rated: 4.16 by PhineasMcClintock from Massachusetts

Jan 15, 2018
Rated: 4.1 by Knapp85 from Pennsylvania

Jan 15, 2018
Photo of mattycliff47
Rated by mattycliff47 from New Jersey

3.78/5  rDev -8.3%
look: 4 | smell: 4 | taste: 3.75 | feel: 3.25 | overall: 3.75
Satisfying. Although feels like a milk stout getting lost a little bit with the BA. That said the bourbon isn't overwhelming.
Jul 18, 2017
Photo of BFCarr
Reviewed by BFCarr from New Jersey

3.99/5  rDev -3.2%
look: 4.25 | smell: 4 | taste: 4 | feel: 3.75 | overall: 4
Pours black with a half inch tan head. Aroma is burbon and roasted notes. Taste is also burbon and roasted notes but neither is overpowering. Feel is a bit astringent, not too much but keeps it from being great. Overall, a nice drinkable BA stout just not best in class.
May 18, 2017
Photo of JerzDevl2000
Reviewed by JerzDevl2000 from New Jersey

4.07/5  rDev -1.2%
look: 4 | smell: 3.75 | taste: 4.25 | feel: 4.25 | overall: 4
Traded for this a while back with a good friend up at the Cloverleaf, as I finally got around to this on yet another rainy spring day. First time ever having anything from Double Nickel as their offerings are not available in this part of the Garden State. Regardless, this was a nice first offering as it had to be one of the smoothest examples of the style that I've had in quite some time, if not ever!

The pour to this was what one would expect from a Stout of this sorts, as the beer was dark, black, and opaque with a moderate amount of toffee head that quickly settled. Lots of bourbon stickiness, toffee, coffee, and espresso in the nose as the more colorful notes came out in the taste. Bitter chocolate, raspberry, oak, caramel, and peat all came out in the taste as the Bourbon came out more but was nicely complemented by the chocolate and berry notes that gave it wonderful depth. A wonderful woody aftertaste served as a reminder as to how this was aged and how this differed from a typical Stout that had stronger roasted and boozier aspects.

Speaking of booze, there was plenty here but it was just the right amount as it complemented the range of flavors without overpowering them. While the fruit and chocolate presence wasn't strong, it was enough to elevate this up another level and keep this from feeling too ashen or sticky. A great brew that came across as an accessible example of this style. Shame that they don't distribute more to these parts!
Apr 12, 2017
Rated: 3.64 by Moestavern from New Jersey

Mar 12, 2017
Photo of q33jeff
Reviewed by q33jeff from New Jersey

4.44/5  rDev +7.8%
look: 4.25 | smell: 4.5 | taste: 4.5 | feel: 4 | overall: 4.5

On tap at blend.

LOOK: dark black, medium light brown head.
AROMA: whiskey dominates,

TASTE: roasted malt, whiskey, pretty smooth.

FEEL: astringent bite, low to medium carbonation.

Very nice BA stout. Just had Weyerbacher SMS before and this hds it's own.
Mar 05, 2017
Rated: 4.25 by waddellc2 from Pennsylvania

Feb 15, 2017
Rated: 4 by DoubleSimcoe from Pennsylvania

Jan 13, 2017
Rated: 4 by TonyTalon from Wisconsin

Jan 12, 2017
Rated: 4.16 by tdm168 from Pennsylvania

Dec 27, 2016
Rated: 4 by Eziel from Ohio

Dec 05, 2016
Rated: 4.75 by Houser from Pennsylvania

Nov 22, 2016
Rated: 4.1 by IckyT2012 from Florida

Sep 11, 2016
Rated: 4.02 by jams1220 from New Jersey

Sep 10, 2016
Photo of MacMalt
Reviewed by MacMalt from New Jersey

4.13/5  rDev +0.2%
look: 4.25 | smell: 4.25 | taste: 4 | feel: 4 | overall: 4.25
Bottle No. 1465 of 1800. Poured into snifter glass. It pours a completely opaque black with one finger of mocha-colored head and lacing that dissipated quickly. It smells of roasted malt, black coffee, dark chocolate, caramel, and only a mild whiff of bourbon. The first taste is the roasted malt and dark chocolate. I'm not tasting the coffee that I smelled. There is a faint taste of caramel and the relatively subtle bourbon is noticeable at the finish. I'm missing the dark fruit that I enjoy in an Imperial Stout. For a stout, it's rather thinly-bodied. On the other hand, the bourbon is subtle and with an ABV of 8.5% it is not overpowering. Overall, after being wowed by Double NIckel's Marbled Buffalo, I was a little let down by the BA Stout. It's good, to be sure, but it lacks the "wow" factor of the BA rye ale.
Sep 04, 2016
Rated: 4 by wonothesane42 from New Jersey

Aug 25, 2016
Rated: 3.92 by BeerForMuscle from New Jersey

Jul 14, 2016
Photo of Jerseybeerboy
Reviewed by Jerseybeerboy from New Jersey

4.73/5  rDev +14.8%
look: 4.75 | smell: 4.75 | taste: 4.75 | feel: 4.5 | overall: 4.75
With the pop up of so many local breweries (some not so good) I am glad to see another great brewery come into the game. A great stout. I really pick up the bourbon in it. Carmel, coffee and vanilla are other flavors I pick up. I can't wait to try more of their beers.
Jun 01, 2016
Photo of NeroFiddled
Reviewed by NeroFiddled from Pennsylvania

4.25/5  rDev +3.2%
look: 4.25 | smell: 4.25 | taste: 4.25 | feel: 4.25 | overall: 4.25
Double Nickel Brewing Company "Buffalo Nickel"
22 fl. oz. brown glass bottle, "Bottle No. 1013 OF 1800" but without freshness dating

Ahhh, I just got it... "Double Nickel" for the bridge, and "Buffalo nickel" for the coins needed to cross given the time frame (the Tacony-Palmyra bridge opened in 1929; Buffalo nickels were minted between 1913 and 1938).

I sampled the stout 4 days ago at the brewery and I wasn't particularly impressed. It was good, maybe even very good, but I thought it was bigger than it needed to be. However, if I'm correct, the beer menu also mentioned that it had been intended for barrel aging, which I can see, and which leads us to the "Buffalo Nickel"...

Appearance: Black. Black as coal. Opaque even when held to direct light except for some thin edges of dark mahogany. And yet it's really not that roasty? How can that be? The head is dark in a similar way, kind of like hot chocolate brown. It's foamy-frothy, and it holds remarkably well. I poured it before I started writing and it's still got a finger-thich head to it. The lacing is quite nice as well. Just keep in mind that it's pretty thick, so if you want a great head and lacing you'll have to give it a bit of a vigorous pour to bring it up (unless something happens in aging it).

Aroma: The aroma, as noted, is not that roasty. So where is all of this darkness coming from? I can't imagine they used black patent malt, but perhaps they did? Or is it just that the Bourbon is over-riding it, because mainly what I find is Bourbon and occasional coconut over dark chocolate and a small amount of oak. It's not complex, but what's there is rich and full (and that will most likely become an ongoing theme).

Flavor: "BAM!", "Shazaam", "I GAWR-ON-TEE", and "Ohhhh, [email protected]#K ME" (I can't think of any more celebrity chef expressions to use, and I'm certainly not going to fall back on Anthony Bourdain's common limp expression of "That's good. No, that's really good"). Everything in the nose follows pretty much as you find it, with the addition of a little bit more oak, some soft yeasty fruitiness (red berries, apple, pear), and a bit more alcohol. It's well-balanced by a stiff bitterness, and surprisingly not overly-acidic, or roasty, or chocolatey, or hot. If this beer was designed as a vessel to carry the Bourbon and oak they've mastered the trick - it delivers pretty much everything right on. Smooth, balanced, rounded - and yet full.

Mouthfeel: Full bodied and smooth with a fine-bubbled, seemingly natural carbonation.

Overall: Impressive, big, almost imperial stout flavor and feel heavily drenched in Bourbon with some oak.
Apr 28, 2016
Rated: 4.75 by JKasten988 from New Jersey

Apr 16, 2016
Rated: 4.2 by rfgetz from New Jersey

Feb 25, 2016
Rated: 4.17 by ColForbinBC from New Jersey

Feb 14, 2016
Buffalo Nickel from Double Nickel Brewing Company
Beer rating: 91 out of 100 with 30 ratings