I'm not familiar with the area to reply with specifics, but I think there are some answers to your question in this thread: http://beeradvocate.com/community/threads/is-3-floyds-brew-pub-worth-it.45888/
Liquor stop in Highland, IN. Then you can go to Beer Geeks Pub as well right around the corner on 45th st, great bar with 20 craft taps and dozens of meads and ciders!