Advice on an overdue trade going sideways

Just to clarify, the list in your first post was the beer you were supposed to receive? Or that was all the beer involved on both sides of the trade? And you're looking for specific dollar values for those beers?

 

If you don't out him, please send me the user's name. Thanks in advance.

 

Please tag this guy and let's get all the facts on the table. Need to get this guy on here and get a resolution for you.

 

This 100%

 

yea that had me confused, because it doesn't say who's was who's

 

Can you repost that and make it clear which is which. Include what original trade was and also what proposed replacement is.

 

This is very simple, either you tell him acceptable bottles or he replaces the exact original bottles. I've been on his side, it sucked, but I bit the bullet (and actually didn't have insurance)

 

If you're just looking for cost, I think the Almanacs were $12 each, the FfaC were $15-$18 each, Golden Blend was $25, HF shelf was $10, HF Sue was $25, and I believe the Cascade was around $25.

 

Op - the values don't matter. He owes you either the original bottles or whatever list of things you come up with which can be based on unicorns or coin flips or whatever measure you use

 

Don't know if it helps at all, but that Cascade would be $25 from the brewery (and maybe elsewhere in Oregon). Here in California that bottle would be $35-40, depending on whether the retailer wants to take a hit on their profits or not because Cascade's wholesale pricing is terrible

 

In Colorado, the Cascade is $30-32, the 3F is ~$24, and Almanac are $10-12.

 

You wouldn't be tainting any value opinions, this would just give us a better idea of what exactly is going on! Seriously, its hard to evaluate the situation without this info and I think @jrnyc would agree with me

 

The HF Florence and Clara would be in the $10-12 range I believe.

 

From the Hill Farmstead site:

• Susan: American IPA 6.2% abv ($8/$16)

 

Am I the only one confused here? Are you allowed to pick 200 points to make up for your $200? If so these values are way off. I get a little increase for older bottles (maybe although I wouldnt) but $35 for florence and Clara? Really? Sounds to me like you aren't getting taken care of the way you should. And since it has been going on for two months you should get additional bottles as well.