BCBSC

way off. I'd say bcbcs = cellar reserve + $20/25. Cellar reserve has fallen off, too

 

BCBCS shouldnt trade for any more that $20 of beer as it is, I cant see it going for a $20+ beer then another $20/25.

OP I do not think you are too far off per se, but it may take the right person as both of these had good distro and the Celler Reserve is still sitting on shelves.

 

How do you get that? Am I missing something?

$4$ is in favor of BCBCS already. I definitely agree BCBCS is harder to get and they might not be a perfect one for one match, but adding another $25 of beer to a $25 bottle for a $20 bottle seems off.

 

Yeah, perhaps I added just a little too much.

 

let me see wich old stock cellar reserve I have. if its 2009 id trade it for a cherry rye

 

I'm sure you would.

 

Seems fair 1:1. Cellar reserve was on shelves forever and has fallen off a good bit. Last time I had it was over a year ago and I thought it had fallen off then.