Best/Worst Trade Extras

Discussion in 'Beer Trading Talk' started by raynmoon, Dec 31, 2013.

  1. RyanMcFly1985

    RyanMcFly1985 Aspirant (231) Oct 20, 2007 Ohio
    Beer Trader

    Traded way way over $4$ for Splinter Gold. Guy just kept asking for more and telling me his friends were telling him I should add more. That was a huge red flag, but whatever...I wanted SG. When I told the dude that I would like $4$ to get a little closer (not even, just less lopsided), dude told me, "Don't worry, you'll be very happy with the box." Old Lagunitas Sucks as an extra (and I live in a Lagunitas distribution area). Total malt bomb for a beer I can get any day right down the street in season. Decided I won't be trading with this guy again. Not a bad trader by any means...but not someone I'll trade with again.
  2. PA-Michigander

    PA-Michigander Meyvn (1,342) Nov 10, 2013 Pennsylvania
    Beer Trader

    I just received a NG Raspberry Tart as an extra recently. Probably the best extra I've received in my young trading time.
    Justdoit1234 and kerry4porters like this.
  3. hookah97

    hookah97 Initiate (0) Jan 8, 2012 Illinois
    Beer Trader

    I was just talking to a guy about a potential trade and then told him that something came up and I couldn't actually go any further with the trade at that point. He understood and sent this unsolicited box for no reason...


    I had never traded with this person before but we had discussed trading once before but nothing came of it that time either. Very generous to say the least.

    Other amazing extras: Fou Foune, T25, Upland sours, Westy 8, Beat5, and so on. I've been incredibly lucky to have found some really exceptional trading partners. I was thrilled to be able to pay back a couple of them with unsolicited Proprietor's this winter.
  4. NeedBeerHere

    NeedBeerHere Initiate (0) Nov 21, 2013 Minnesota

    I think my best extra was an 2009 BCBS bomber but that was a couple years ago. Still a generous extra. It was in a trade for a BCBVS.
  5. sacrelicio

    sacrelicio Initiate (0) Feb 15, 2005 Minnesota

    That is a killer IPA. We get it here in MN and it's easily one of the best IPAs you can buy.
  6. jshusc

    jshusc Defender (656) Aug 16, 2013 South Carolina
    Beer Trader

    Best: Zombie Dust, Velvet Merkin, Pliny

    Worst: Backwoods Bastard (tongue firmly in cheek) (I've received really good extras, and this is honestly the worst...and I love it! Goes to show you the vast majority of BAs are good peeps).
    JavaNoire likes this.
  7. phishphorce

    phishphorce Initiate (0) Aug 4, 2011 Pennsylvania


    Beatificaiton B5 and or Saison Bernice


    Old IPA's
  8. tinypyramids

    tinypyramids Initiate (0) Jul 19, 2012 Illinois

    best received: row 2 hill 56 growler plus a temptation in a totally unsolicited box.
    worst received: not technically an extra, but a BIF box (not from this site) that was half filled with beers i could get easily by walking three blocks. however, the dude way way made up for it in a followup trade.

    best sent: fou foune
    worst sent: i don't send shitty extras. maybe beers you might not wind up liking, but i'm extremely careful to at least keep things in-code and also only send stuff outside the recipients distro zone.
  9. Sarge3130

    Sarge3130 Devotee (480) May 13, 2012 Pennsylvania
    Beer Trader

    what i thought at the time, Best: 2013 Darklord

    Worst: drank 2013 darklord
    concealed, mythaeus and Johnnyhitch like this.
  10. NuclearRich

    NuclearRich Initiate (0) Apr 10, 2009 Connecticut
    Beer Trader

    lol, you got a collectors item? empty bottle? Maybe UPS/FedEx figured it out and is a beer guy and stole it
  11. Sarge3130

    Sarge3130 Devotee (480) May 13, 2012 Pennsylvania
    Beer Trader

    i meant when i got the darklord i was excited, then i drank it and was quickly dissappointed. thought that counts though i guess.
    Johnnyhitch likes this.
  12. RustyP

    RustyP Aspirant (201) Dec 22, 2008 Texas
    Beer Trader

    Best extra: I drove to OKC to make in IP trade with blueokie...not only did he go out of his way to meet me on short notice, but he brought a Bottleworks XII just in case I hadn't tried it before! Luckily I came armed with an extra Jester King sour and some other stuff, but his extra was still way better :)
    beerboy9960 likes this.
  13. robgage

    robgage Zealot (534) Dec 19, 2013 Pennsylvania
    Beer Trader

    Best: FiftyFifty Eclipse Elijah Craig 12yr

    Worst: Nothing.... COME ON MAN!
    Badfish likes this.
  14. beernuts

    beernuts Disciple (373) Jan 23, 2014 Virginia
    Beer Trader

    So what exactly is the protocol regarding extras? Are they expected? Would it be considered bad form to not send any extras or are they truly bonus beers? I'm not a trader, just curious.
  15. Hopheadhiker

    Hopheadhiker Devotee (444) Mar 21, 2013 New York
    Beer Trader

    Best received: Bottleworks XII & Beachwood Tovarish in same trade
    Best Given: Lawson's Maple Barrel Aged Fayston
    Worst such thing
    mythaeus, CarolinaKevin and matt2591 like this.
  16. Bieniek30

    Bieniek30 Disciple (380) Mar 24, 2013 New York
    Beer Trader

    Best Recieved: Gumballhead
    Best Given: BCBS
  17. raczkowski

    raczkowski Disciple (319) May 16, 2011 Florida
    Beer Trader

    best: black Tuesday with a regular trading partner
    worst: proably a selection of organic beers recently. florida gets their distro and the beers were mediocre at best.

    trading on here is getting harder and harder every day with people holding their beer ransom. luckily, I have made trade partners in almost all parts of the country so we typically make good on most trades. I am also in a beer group on facebook and that has been the best thing to happen to my beer cellar. there are still some great BAs out there, but the forums are starting to get filled with some real munsons that want the world for their "rare" flavor of the week.
    mctizzz, tripsforjoe and core42 like this.
  18. mythaeus

    mythaeus Champion (815) Jul 22, 2013 Pennsylvania
    Beer Trader

    I can't really say "best received" because these were awesome for each trade: BCBCS, CW 16, 3F Oude Gueuze, Westy 12, PtE, Sour in the Rye

    Worst: unlabeled bottle, trading partner said it's either home brew or some (name omitted) beer with missing label

    "Best" given: 1/2lbs bag of curry beef jerky made by my extended family. I usually give this out to my repeat trade partner in addition to other extras.
    robgage and beernuts like this.
  19. fishmich

    fishmich Devotee (411) Apr 11, 2013 Michigan
    Beer Trader

    no extras is bad form unless it was in the trade agreement.

    best sent: BBPT5th or Kuhnhenn meads

    best received: Parabola
  20. striker2160

    striker2160 Disciple (391) May 5, 2013 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    Beer geek brunch weasal and BA Framinghammer on the same trade. The best given Surly Darkness.
  21. mlhyatt

    mlhyatt Devotee (496) Jul 27, 2013 Georgia
    Beer Trader

    Best recieved: psuedosue, zombie dust, big bad baptist, raspberry tart, and some of central waters barrel program beers.

    Best given: DB Huna, bcs, bcbbw

    Worst recieved: innis &gunn winter porter. But i'm not complaining.

    Worst given: probably old heathen
  22. jdb288

    jdb288 Initiate (0) Nov 22, 2013 New Jersey

    Best Received: Hill Farmstead Everett
  23. JMaxwell

    JMaxwell Initiate (0) Oct 18, 2012 Maryland
    Beer Trader

    I'm still fairly new to trading but in one of my first trades I sent out a 6-pack of OTWOA for a 4-pack of Heady. When I received my package I found two extra cans of Heady Topper, along with another local IPA. I was thrilled to say the least and couldn't help but share the wealth with a couple friends who also love beer.
  24. ESCO138

    ESCO138 Aspirant (233) Dec 10, 2013 California
    Beer Trader

    Best Given: FW XVII
    Best Received: BA Framinghammer.
    Worst: Nothing [Not mad if extras not mentioned].
  25. AJ01923

    AJ01923 Devotee (414) Jan 1, 2013 Massachusetts
    Beer Trader

    Surly Coffee Bender. It came as an extra and I immediately went back and set up a trade for 8 more!
  26. epic1856

    epic1856 Initiate (0) Aug 11, 2006 California
    Beer Trader

    Best: Heady Topper
    Worst: None received (I'm ok with it though)
  27. markgugs

    markgugs Initiate (0) Dec 20, 2006 New Jersey
    Beer Trader

    I just got an Abyss 2013 :eek:
    AndrewPalmer likes this.
  28. lurpy1

    lurpy1 Zealot (565) Jan 15, 2010 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    FW16 is the best extra. there is no worst extra.
  29. maDUECEgunner

    maDUECEgunner Initiate (0) May 23, 2013 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    Best given: Darkness. (wedding present) with Bell's wedding ale
    Best received 2012 Abyss
  30. teledeluxe

    teledeluxe Initiate (0) Nov 21, 2013 Illinois
    Beer Trader

    I personally think that's a fun extra.
  31. fishmich

    fishmich Devotee (411) Apr 11, 2013 Michigan
    Beer Trader

    got this one today, the BT, Bois and Sucaba were extras.
  32. JohnnyHopps

    JohnnyHopps Meyvn (1,323) Jun 15, 2010 Indiana
    Beer Trader

    Aside from recognizable extras, i try to throw in stuff from small local brewpubs that don' t suck. Is this a violation of extra etiquette?
  33. Ckoz

    Ckoz Disciple (305) Feb 15, 2014 Michigan
    Beer Trader

    Jesus who did you trade with ha
    TrojanRB and concealed like this.
  34. fishmich

    fishmich Devotee (411) Apr 11, 2013 Michigan
    Beer Trader

    traded with badb_rad. enjoying one of those Parabolas right now getting ready for the Spartans!
    concealed likes this.
  35. Ckoz

    Ckoz Disciple (305) Feb 15, 2014 Michigan
    Beer Trader

    Go Green. Enjoy
    concealed likes this.
  36. ChrisChagnon

    ChrisChagnon Initiate (0) Jul 9, 2013 Connecticut
    Beer Trader

    Recent non-ba guy, trade was for 3-5 bible belts. Ended up being 6 bible belts, 2 bomb!, 2 prarie noir and 2 ten fidy!
  37. nc41

    nc41 Meyvn (1,359) Sep 25, 2008 North Carolina
    Beer Trader

    I'm down to a few regular trade partners, they all add great xtra stuff, great beer, glassware etc. Kinda gets to be a competition to add good stuff they can't daily get.
    twizzard, shoegueuze and markgugs like this.
  38. lonewolfcry

    lonewolfcry Zealot (561) Dec 7, 2007 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    Best received: Elijah Craig Eclipse 20yr & Better Half - in the same box :eek::eek:
    Best given: Backyard Rye & Black Note - same box
    kingkong likes this.
  39. arlingtonjoe

    arlingtonjoe Devotee (427) Jan 20, 2013 Illinois
    Beer Trader

    Best received would have been marshall wharf cant dog or a 2 year vertical of kbs.
    Best received from a BA who trades regularly and comes to tastings at our local mom & pop would be heady, psuedo sue 7, and OTWOA from dc brau and we were just sharing beers.
    Worst would have been a 21 month old cherise from founders. gotta love a vintage fruit beer. lol. :confused:
  40. bsnone

    bsnone Aspirant (245) Nov 22, 2012 Arizona
    Beer Trader

    Best: Was sent a box containing Zombie Dust and Alpha Klaus around Christmas from an awesome regular trader. Never had had either at the time, both are no some of my favorites.

    Best given: I've sent BCBCS after I had to delay shipping about a 7-10 days. Also sent Abyss to someone out of the Deschutes distro.

    I've really had some serious awesome extras but the box out of the blue was pretty slick.
    creepinjeeper likes this.
  • About Us

    Your go-to website for beer (since 1996), publishers of BeerAdvocate magazine (since 2006) and hosts of world-class beer events (since 2003). Respect Beer.
  • BeerAdvocate Microbrew Invitational

    Join us June 2-3, 2017 in Boston, Mass. for beer, cider, mead, kombucha and sake from over 70 small producers.

    Learn More
  • Subscribe to BeerAdvocate Magazine

    Support uncompromising beer advocacy and award-winning, independent journalism with a print subscription to BeerAdvocate magazine.