Where's it available other than the brewery? Beer Menus has it only at Good Beer in Manhattan, growlers only.
I got a 4-pack at WF Chelsea. It wasn't cheap, $18 after tax, but it was worth it. To be completely honest, if I had drank it blind I would put it up against any of the NYC breweries.
Just tried Powder Dreams (Citra) and I must say I'm impressed. I give Captain Lawrence a lot of credit for helping to pioneer craft beer in the area but have felt for a while now that their beers are a solid step or two behind the best that the larger area around them has to offer. But this one gives me hope... the brewery has always been a lot of fun to visit, but if they can more consistently offer beers at this level it would really be something else.