Cellar Reviews (2020)

Discussion in 'Cellaring / Aging Beer' started by TheGent, Jan 1, 2020.

  1. TheGent

    TheGent Poo-Bah (2,103) Jun 29, 2010 New Jersey
    Society Trader

    Kicking off the new thread for 2020. Let’s see what your cellars have to offer in the New Year!
     
  2. TheGent

    TheGent Poo-Bah (2,103) Jun 29, 2010 New Jersey
    Society Trader

    Dogfish Head Olde School

    A Barleywine style ale brewed with figs and dates. 15% ABV. Bottled on 12/17/2016.

    [​IMG]

    Look: Pours a murky, but translucent medium to deep amber color. A finger of beige head quickly disappears leaving a ring of foam around the edge of the glass. No visible carbonation.

    Smell: Figs, dates, burnt sugar, and some warming alcohol. Sweet fruit cake. Some tobacco. Candy hazelnut.

    Taste: Sweet, dark dried fruit on the tip of the tongue. Figs and dates. Bready, with some faint yeast esters as well. The alcohol is quite present and a little fusel in nature. The website says 85 IBU. Take that for what you will, but this beer is quite hoppy with some lemon rind bitterness.

    Feel: Medium level of carbonation, and quite dry and bitter on the finish.

    Overall: No aging issues here. After three years this beer is still quite boozy and very hoppy. I prefer English Barleywine over American, but I do enjoy both. And this one combines elements from the two. I enjoy drinking this beer because the dark fruit flavors are nice without being overly sweet as the finish dries and bitters out. It is still pretty hot so I look forward to seeing how the hops and alcohol change a year from now. Definitely prefer this beer with age.
     
  3. SiepJones

    SiepJones Zealot (554) Nov 20, 2008 Pennsylvania
    Trader

    Happy New Year all! My first post in a while. I greatly enjoyed lurking this forum in 2019. Last night I had a beer that I enjoyed so much I needed to share. With 2019 coming to a close I thought it was time to drink my last 2009 Bigfoot. I haven't had a Bigfoot Ale since 2016, which was coincidently a 2009 as well, and that was also the oldest Bigfoot I'd had at 7 years of age. I love Bigfoot, fresh or aged, and it was one of the beers that not only got me into cellar/aging but craft beer in general. The problem is I want to drink it right away. I'm glad that somehow I let this one slip off my radar and get to the 10 year mark.
    For starters the pour produced a thick and creamy head. I did not pour aggressively and I expected the beer to be on the flat side. It looked like it was just bottled. The nose was a rich with figgy malt. The taste was out of this world. Flavors of doughy malt with some sweet raisins and fig. It reminded me of a sticky bun with raisins, although not as sweet. The balance of the flavor and its richness is what really struck me. There wasn't a trace of oxidation. I took my time with it allowing it to warm up and its full flavor profile to shine. The mouthfeel was thick and chewy. I didn't notice the carbonation although it was there (as exhibited by the head).

    I loved this beer. It felt like this age was the exact right time to drink it as it seemed to be at its peak without any signs of drop off. I have three 2010's left and then I'm all out. Looking forward to enjoying what I have and restocking. Hopefully I can have some patience/willpower to hang onto a bottle or two for another 10 years or maybe more.


    [​IMG]
     
  4. liquorpig

    liquorpig Savant (975) Sep 6, 2008 Massachusetts
    Society

    2013 - Stone Farking Wheaton. I believe this is the 1st vintage. Poured with little to no head. Carbonation still present to my surprise. Aroma of dark fruit. Taste includes notes of dark chocolate, cherries, barrel, dark fruit and some alcohol heat. Smooth feel with some viscosity. Overall, a decent beer. The heat from the 13% abv is still pretty evident. I thought it would have mellowed out by now.
    [​IMG]
     
  5. neenerzig

    neenerzig Poo-Bah (2,228) Feb 15, 2006 Ohio

  6. tobelerone

    tobelerone Poo-Bah (2,749) Dec 1, 2010 New York
    Society Trader

    Drank this one on New Year’s Eve and I was stunned at how great it was: 2009 JW Lees sherry barrel aged. Carbonation was low but there was just enough life left that it wasn’t totally still; there was a lot of floaty particle matter at the bottom of the glass but there was still a decent head from a vigorous pour and a nicely full and silky feel. Flavor was just nuts, really close to a Pedro ximenez sherry but more complex; there was a ton of dark fruit sweetness and interesting oxidized character, toasted bread and nuts and vinous notes. I was a little worried this would be well over the hill but it just nailed the sweet spot for me. There are some 2010 and 2012 bottles hanging around in the same store I will try to get back to before long. I had a calvados bottle of similar age that wasn’t quite as appealing but something about the sherry treatment is just perfect.
     
    kemoarps, Beersnake1, DIM and 4 others like this.
  7. tobelerone

    tobelerone Poo-Bah (2,749) Dec 1, 2010 New York
    Society Trader

    Another recent selection was a 2011 Affligem Noel I scored sitting on the dusty shelves of a smoke shop - the proprietor just gave it to me when I bought a bottle of bourbon county. It was only slightly worse for wear in that the carbonation might have been a little lower than desirable and the flavors just slightly muted but it was still a solid Belgian dark ale even after all those years of storage in completely poor environs. Obviously
    These beers hold up really well over the long haul even if 8-9 years might be a little much. I don’t think the Affligem is a top of class beer at its best (solid b?) and I’m dubious of holding stuff like westy 12 or abt 12 for over a decade like some have suggested although of course I’d like to drink them and decide for myself. For science.
     
    kemoarps, Beersnake1, DIM and 5 others like this.
  8. CaptainHate

    CaptainHate Savant (959) Apr 22, 2006 Ohio
    Society

    2018 Stone Brewing Fyodor

    4.29/5 rDev -4%
    look: 4.5 | smell: 4.25 | taste: 4.25 | feel: 4.5 | overall: 4.25

    Brewed 1/25/2018. Had trouble removing the cork and had the resort to a corkscrew. Poured most of a 500 ml bottle into a DFH tulip. The body was as dark as Rasputin's soul with an ample tan head. Drinking in a 58 degree room everything got better as it reached room temperature. At first everything seemed thin with the char dominating but eventually the other flavors prevailed. Never specifically noticed the anise in smell or taste but lots of dark fruits and barrel were present. Mouthfeel was fine for a big stout.

    Maybe I've been spoiled by BCBS and Jackie O's barrel aged stouts but this just didn't deliver what I was hoping it would. Maybe I'll try it again to see if this was just a subjective one time thing. It wasn't bad by any reasonable criteria but just wasn't the knock it out of the park experience I was hoping for.
     
    kemoarps, TheGent, Beersnake1 and 7 others like this.
  9. Beer_Economicus

    Beer_Economicus Zealot (538) Apr 8, 2017 Indiana
    Trader

    You are not alone. Early in my beer adventures, before I ever had BCBS (which is currently my favorite BA stout), I tried two BA stouts from Stone; one was Fyodor. I knew immediately that it was “fine,” but not amazing, even without much comparison. It’s Alright, but not worth the price. Under no circumstances should it be more than $5 for a 12oz (not that it is sold in that format), considering the size of the brewery, and honestly, it should really be probably a tad cheaper, but at least at that price I might be willing to buy it once in awhile. At it’s current and past pricing, not a chance.
     
  10. unlikelyspiderperson

    unlikelyspiderperson Meyvn (1,137) Mar 12, 2013 California
    Society Trader

    First trek to the cellar in the new year. Bell's 30th Anniversary Cherry Stout Reserve. Bottled 5/11/2018 in honor of the beer's (not the breweries) 30th anniversary.
    Just shy of 20 months in the bottle, I only held this one for science as I found the year old version to have already fallen far from it's pleasant character fresh. This one may have pulled itself back together a bit or perhaps I'm just in a better mood today.
    The pour yields an inky cherrywood colored liquid capped by a minimal head even with an aggressive pour.
    Immediately the room is filled with the aroma of cherry cough syrup. Upon closer inspection the aroma is very boozy cherry cough syrup esque with notes of stale red wine and rain soaked charred wood. Not appealing frankly.
    And the taste is only marginally better with tart black cherry juice dominating the flavor along with off brand cola. Reminds me of some sort of natural cherry based cough syrup in the taste as well.
    Body is simultaneously thin and overly syrupy.
    All in all I'm not finishing this beer and I'm glad to be rid of them. I suppose that a certain type of person might really enjoy this, someone who regularly drinks tart cherry juice, perhaps someone who is eating the right sort of creamy dessert? Not me though, I originally gave it a 3.84 fresh, now I would probably put it at about a 2.84. Would not recommend and if you are still holding onto any of these I'd be inclined to sit on it for another 6-12 months and see if anything changes
     
  11. landrewg

    landrewg Initiate (149) Nov 11, 2008 Michigan
    Trader

    Found a dusty 4-pack of Founders Breakfast Stout dated 10/30/2015 and had to buy it.
    Coffee, coffee, coffee! No carb, but smells and tastes like an iced coffee. The creamy BS mouth feel is gone. As it got warmer I got a little chocolate and liked it a lot better.
    Would not recommend aging this long but it pretty decent and I will finish the 4-pack!
     
  12. Beersnake1

    Beersnake1 Poo-Bah (2,280) Aug 17, 2013 California
    Society Trader

    2017 Stille Nacht from De Dolle. Tons of head on the pour. Nose is red wine, toffee, sap, pears, malts, bread, and some dull lemon notes. Taste follows the nose - sweet fruity/wine notes are upfront. A touch of bitterness on the finish. Grass, leather, toffee, candy, and peaches come through. Overall, this is a brilliant and complex beer that ages beautifully.

    [​IMG]
     
    kemoarps, DIM, strohme2 and 7 others like this.
  13. Bitterbill

    Bitterbill Poo-Bah (6,990) Sep 14, 2002 Wyoming
    Society Trader

    The no carbonation surprised me but I betcha it aged better than the same year's KBS.:wink:
     
    landrewg likes this.
  14. Bitterbill

    Bitterbill Poo-Bah (6,990) Sep 14, 2002 Wyoming
    Society Trader

    I had a 2010 in 2011 and it was hot as hell. I said to myself at the time...this could use some cellaring. You just proved it. Prost!
     
    landrewg and Beersnake1 like this.
  15. SiepJones

    SiepJones Zealot (554) Nov 20, 2008 Pennsylvania
    Trader

    Just a friendly PSA/Reminder to drink these. Almost 2 years old. I wasn't in a rush to finish off what I had left and I took for granted that it doesn't age graceful. It was good. No unsavory flavors. Bourbon barrel was strong but the chocolate, coffee, etc was a bit muted (of course). These flavors seem to have more pop when fresh. So get out there and do the right thing, and remember sharing's caring.

    [​IMG] [​IMG]
     
  16. Beersnake1

    Beersnake1 Poo-Bah (2,280) Aug 17, 2013 California
    Society Trader

    Agreed! This evolves into something amazing!
     
    landrewg and Bitterbill like this.
  17. Beersnake1

    Beersnake1 Poo-Bah (2,280) Aug 17, 2013 California
    Society Trader

    2012 Fruet. Nose is sherry, bourbon, cherries, a touch of oxidation, candy, toffee, brown sugar, marmalade, and some oak. Taste is super smooth, although the age is definitely detectable. A small amount of oxidation is present, but in no way off-putting. A well-rounded beer, with nice notes of bourbon, dark fruit, malts, yeast, and toffee. Very nice stuff. Can't believe I have held on to this for so long.

    [​IMG]
     
    kemoarps, DIM, strohme2 and 7 others like this.
  18. CaptainHate

    CaptainHate Savant (959) Apr 22, 2006 Ohio
    Society

    2012 North Coast Brewing Co. Old Stock Ale

    Drinking the next to last of the 2012s as I like to begin the year with one of these, my first introduction into the joys of English old ales. Still plenty of carbonation as poured into a DFH tulip but the color has darkened into a reddish dark amber. Before I get into any tasting notes, like an idiot I brushed my teeth before enjoying this because my post dinner mouth tasted like hot garbage. Be that as it may, adding an artificial mint to my palate completely screwed everything. It's been an unusually warm January day here, as in the windows are open, so it did get to warm up more than usual at this time of the year.

    Even after it warmed up the smell was very muted. There was some vanilla and dark fruit but not to the level I was expecting. The taste was initially more fusil than I was previously accustomed to but as it warmed up, and that fucking artificial mint subsided, a richer taste of vanilla, brown sugar and dark fruit took over. I hadn't planned on doing a vertical with subsequent years but maybe when I enjoy the last one I'll do it for comparison purposes. Because, even though these are capable of being aged far in excess of eight years according to the brewer, maybe the optimum spot has been exceeded.
     
    kemoarps, DIM, Bitterbill and 3 others like this.
  19. unlikelyspiderperson

    unlikelyspiderperson Meyvn (1,137) Mar 12, 2013 California
    Society Trader

    2017(maybe 2016) Central Waters BBA Stout

    Picked this up at a normally reliable bottle shop near my folks during the holidays, turns out it has changed ownership and they have given up inventory management. I was hardpressed to find many of the prominent localish brewers hoppy offerings under 8 months and I found this 4-pack that is either 2+ or 3+ years old (CW uses the label notch method to denote vintage and this one seems about 80% certain to be 2017 but it is not spot on on any of the bottles)

    Pours a lovely mahogany brown with a decent cocoa colored head.
    The nose is Prunes through the roof as soon as you pop the cap. This is the dominant aroma throughout, supported by a pleasantly bitter tobacco, a stale bourbon and cola note, and a pleasant fig and raisin heavy fruit cake note.

    Taste hits with chocolate/mocha at first at cellar temp with a rising vanilla creme note and the same fig/raisin fruit cake growing in prominence as the beer warms.

    The feel is smooth and somewhat light.

    I haven't had this specific beer fresh that I can recall but I've had cassian and peruvian sunset fresh and this is much subdued in terms of flavor intensity. However it is also very well melded and coherent and I suspect that this is near the peak of it's quality, maybe just a bit past. Definitely would be buying a few more packs of this aged stuff (16$ a 4-pack!) if I lived over there
     
    kemoarps, DIM, Bitterbill and 5 others like this.
  20. CoreyC

    CoreyC Aspirant (205) Mar 16, 2015 Wisconsin

    This is one of the beers that I am aging from his birth year until my grandson turns 21. Just picked up the 2017 for my granddaughter as it didn't seem fair that she'd miss out (assuming they hold up!).
     
  21. kemoarps

    kemoarps Poo-Bah (1,546) Apr 30, 2008 Washington
    Trader

    Ah yes welcome to the new year indeed. We're doing a little side by side of the 2018 and 2019 Grandfather Raven from Black Raven (released in December of each year as best as I can tell).
    Black Raven claims to put easy to read date codes, but that does not bear out on these bottles. Still, I think I figured them out: The one I had in the 'cellar' reads: 1801091348, which I take to mean 2018, December 14th (348th day of the year). Not sure what the ...01091... is about though. The 2019 bottle that I bought this evening reads: 1905101319, which I take to be November 14th 2019. Whose knows.

    [​IMG]

    They're both beautiful once again. My original review from 2015 noted the large satin head, and those are true again here. The younger one looks a little lacier/billowier while the 2018 looks a little more subdued, but that could be imagination or simple pour variation or whatever.

    The newer one has an aroma of dried cocoa/dusty chocolate powder, some roasty character and coffee. The year old one though... super rich. Markedly more luxuriant feeling... fudge vs cocoa powder. Original review mentioned both of those directions.

    Bitter chocolate and coffee and again a drier sharper profile on the fresher bottle. The aged one is more blended and mellowed and perhaps even a little shaved off? Duller. The bitter finish of black coffee and bakers chocolate stands out more on the 2018, as the 2019 flavours are still a little more vibrant and pronounced each on their own.

    The fresher one definitely strikes me as more oily/sticky while the 2018 has a little drier thing going on.

    [​IMG]

    These are both really tasty, but I think I actually like this fresher on the flavour, even if the aroma on the 2018 was preferable. Either one is still quite good, though.
     
  22. Whyteboar

    Whyteboar Initiate (99) Jun 7, 2008 Michigan
    Trader

    Thank you for the timely review; I was wondering if I should check how mine turned out as the first time I had it (last March?) it was almost exactly as you describe above. I'll put a little note on it not to open until 2021 at the earliest. Very odd as Larry Bell generally knows what the heck he's doing.
     
  23. unlikelyspiderperson

    unlikelyspiderperson Meyvn (1,137) Mar 12, 2013 California
    Society Trader

    Ya this was a weird one for me, really enjoyed it fresh and then it fell apart soooo quickly even though Bell's typically on point guidelines for consumption list it as unlimited shelf life. Be interested to see your thoughts after another year
     
    kemoarps and Whyteboar like this.
  24. Bitterbill

    Bitterbill Poo-Bah (6,990) Sep 14, 2002 Wyoming
    Society Trader

    [​IMG]

    I reckon that it is a wee bit past it's prime. Some astringent/sharpness to it. Still not close to being a drain pour. Bought off a shelf today.
     
  25. Beersnake1

    Beersnake1 Poo-Bah (2,280) Aug 17, 2013 California
    Society Trader

    2017 oak-aged World Wide Stout. Nose is really interesting. Lots of molasses, oak, leather, dark fruit, and marshmallow. The taste is insanely smooth. Lots of toffee, brown sugar, vanilla, oak, and a bit of nuttiness. Definitely some big roasted malts. This one has mellowed out a little bit since bottled, and it seems a bit sweeter to me. The crazy high ABV is really not detectable for me. Big thick mouthfeel.

    [​IMG]
     
    Budlum, Bitterbill, SiepJones and 5 others like this.
  26. maximum12

    maximum12 Poo-Bah (4,234) Jan 21, 2008 Minnesota
    Trader

    I've had Abyss up to 8 years old that was still very good. I wonder if it was light-struck sitting on the shelf all that time; but I also haven't aged any vintages after 2013.
     
    bl00 and Bitterbill like this.
  27. CaptainHate

    CaptainHate Savant (959) Apr 22, 2006 Ohio
    Society

    2018 North Coast Brewing Old Rasputin

    1/25/2018 12 ounce bottle. Large tan head over a dark brown body. Rich chocolate infused malty smell. Taste is much creamier and mellow with the hop bite lessened from fresh with complex dark fruit flavors making their presence known. Not boozy per se but you know you're drinking something with heft, the type of brew that Catherine the Great wanted transported large distances for her enjoyment on the long Russian nights.

    Someone here said the sweet spot for this was two years. I still have three of these left and I suspect at least two of these will be consumed by the end of spring. This is very good.
     
  28. Whyteboar

    Whyteboar Initiate (99) Jun 7, 2008 Michigan
    Trader

    Was this the BBA or WBA? I enjoy them both very much but find my palate enjoying the BBA more than the Rye Whiskey aged variety. Either way, thanks for the heads up on the expiration date, I’ll have to cycle mine.
     
  29. neenerzig

    neenerzig Poo-Bah (2,228) Feb 15, 2006 Ohio

    unlikelyspiderperson likes this.
  30. kemoarps

    kemoarps Poo-Bah (1,546) Apr 30, 2008 Washington
    Trader

    So I've got a vertical of Anchor Our Special Ale going back to like... 2005? Missing one or two years but for the most part. Anyway. I'm getting ready to move, and as such have been doing some organizing/packing. As a part of this the GF and I went through my 'celllar' to chart and organize. I commented on how I was surprised that I hadn't come across this years vintage yet, which surprised me since it's usually everywhere. Well, she took it upon herself and decided dammit, we were going to find it tonight. Calling around the city I think we literally found the last six pack in Seattle.
    So of course after that we had to crack into one tonight when we got home. And naturally, I was going to pull one of them out of the cellar to compare. 2014 is the lucky year.

    [​IMG]

    The current edition is creamy and sweet. I don't know if I am anywhere close to on base, but the impression I have is corn and melanoidin malts and some earthy german hops.

    [​IMG]

    The 2014 has really transformed. Reading back at my 'new' review (which I drank at about a year), I got a lot of interesting spices and some berry sweetness. I described it as being, "somewhere between a fruitcake and a rumcake." with the flavour leaning towards the fruitcake, with doughy fruity spicy notes.
    Now here some five years later it has leaned way into that rumcake. The doughy fruit character has all but faded into a silky smoothe body, and the flavour is overwhelmingly mild rum and Dr. Pepper. At least to me. One of the more interesting transformations I've experienced in this series of experiments, even if I liked it better fresh
     
    bl00 and strohme2 like this.
  31. Mongrel

    Mongrel Crusader (750) Feb 14, 2013 Maryland
    Trader

    Happened upon one of these a local hole-in-the-wall shop recently and picked it up. I was also blown away by how insanely smooth and delicious it was. I drank a bunch of these fresh and now it's drinking perhaps better than ever. Would love to find a couple more.
     
    Beersnake1 and bl00 like this.