Considering a sour imperial stout experiment...

Discussion in 'Homebrewing' started by gcg49, Aug 15, 2015.

Tags:
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. gcg49

    gcg49 Initiate (0) Dec 29, 2014 Texas

    So, I brewed an imperial stout earlier this year. Bottled it with priming sugar, and it does not seem to be carbonating after 2+ months in the bottle. This is really only my second attempt at a big beer, and beer #1 carbed with no issues after roughly the same time frame. Go figure. Ignoring the extra sweetness from the priming sugar and the lack of carb, it tastes pretty mediocre. I've got around a case of these bottles.

    Planning on bottling a Flanders red in a few months. I am considering cracking these bottles and carefully racking them on top of the yeast trub. I would probably add some strawberries or other fruit as well, which I would just buy frozen, let thaw, and throw in a blender.

    Any thoughts or concerns with this approach? Would the wild yeast struggle with a 10% ABV stout? Am I in trouble from an oxidation standpoint?

    And as far as general process goes... Is it always good practice to add additional yeast at bottling for larger beers or beers that have been aging? What is a good rule of thumb or cutoff point where you should definitely add more? Are the rules different when it comes to wild yeast?
     
  2. bgjohnston

    bgjohnston Initiate (0) Jan 14, 2009 Connecticut

    You could try this and it might work out pretty well. I read in one of my books that a straight stout can be balanced in the glass with a sour beer, too. I think that was in American Sour Beers by @OldSock in the chapter on blending.
     
  3. OldSock

    OldSock Maven (1,418) Apr 3, 2005 District of Columbia

    Because of the substantial alcohol it likely won't sour much (depending on the strains you have in there), but the Brett should dry it out. However, that a may or may not improve the beer. I wouldn't design a recipe for a funky RIS the same as a clean one, I'd back down on the roast and bitterness.

    You may be better off rehydrating some wine yeast and adding that to the bottles. Most of my big spots take 6+ months to come into their own.

    Yep Flemish Red with Imperial Stout makes a great combo in the glass. Cuts the roast, and adds sweetness to balance the acidity.
     
    machalel and ChrisMyhre like this.
  4. gcg49

    gcg49 Initiate (0) Dec 29, 2014 Texas

    Thanks for the replies. I have also considered cracking the bottles, pouring into a corny keg, and adding some yeast. I may do half and half just because this experiment sounds entertaining and I have no other plans to reuse the sour yeast.
     
  5. bevoduz

    bevoduz Initiate (0) Oct 29, 2007 Illinois

    3 years ago I brewed a 13% abv Ris, then aged it in a keg with cherries and bourbon soaked oak for a while. I transferred it off the cherries put it in the cellar. About a year ago I still hadn't drank it because the few times I pulled a sample it just tasted slightly off. Not infected, just off, couldn't pin point it. So a few days later I decided to dump the dregs of a bottle of tart of darkness in there.

    I've heard roasty beers don't sour well, but really had nothing to lose, just figured I'd be dumping it anyway.

    Fast forward to the 4th of July this year. I decided to chill it and carbonate it and sample with friends since we had a party.

    Results, it turned out amazing! No one could guess the base style, but there's an amazing amount of sourness and it actually worked!
     
    gcg49 likes this.
  6. LakesideBrewing

    LakesideBrewing Zealot (604) Dec 1, 2013 Massachusetts
    Trader

    I brewed a fairly large (10.5%) RIS and bottled it. I tried my first bottle at the two month mark and I was severely disappointed: flat(ish) and too boozy. I almost panicked and thought about dumping the bottles into a keg, but I (thankfully) got too busy and it never happened. 6 months after that I tried one and was blown away. It turned out being one of the best beers that I had ever brewed in the 25 years that I've been homebrewing. Patience, my friend.

    -Mike
     
    bushycook likes this.
  7. gcg49

    gcg49 Initiate (0) Dec 29, 2014 Texas

    I understand the idea that a RIS would take a long time to hit it's stride, but where do you draw the line between yeast needing more time and just not having enough viable yeast to carb? I figured that having a totally flat beer with no indication of progression that tastes sweet from the bottling sugar after 2+ months meant I was out of luck.
     
  8. gcg49

    gcg49 Initiate (0) Dec 29, 2014 Texas

    So, update here. After bottling my flanders red, I went ahead and dumped the equivalent of 2 gal of the RIS bottles onto the wild yeast trub along with a big jar of homemade strawberry jam (as a side note, I have read bad things about pectin, but this is a total science experiment at this point anyway so I'm not so concerned).

    After 3 months, the bottles had varying degrees of carb ranging from totally flat to a very mild carb. I tasted many of the bottles and it was not very good. Beyond the carbonation problem and sweetness, I think there was too much roasted malt. Oh well. I still have a portion of the bottles to let sit and check on after 6+ months. If it turns out to finally carb and taste much better, cool. I am okay with the sacrifice to have some fun here.

    Anyway, moving on. I have been concerned about 1. oxidation from pouring bottles and 2. the nearly 10%ABV and high IBU would just kill the yeast and inhibit souring. After pouring the bottles onto the trub, I was home for 4 days and left on a trip. During those four days, there was a tiny bit of airlock activity but no krausen. I returned home 11 days after racking and to my surprise there is a healthy layer of krausen and a lot of airlock activity! I don't have high expectations but this seems to be a good sign.
     
    PapaGoose03 and machalel like this.
  9. gcg49

    gcg49 Initiate (0) Dec 29, 2014 Texas

    Took my first sample today. The beer is very sour and dry, which seems to have cut through the overwhelming roast character. A little bit of strawberry on the nose, and there is a tinge of red in the color, but overall the sour qualities have taken over. Pretty excited and now wishing I didn't hold back so many of the RIS bottles, ha! My mind is creeping towards the possibility of doubling down and adding even more of the bottles and strawberries, but even I am not stupid enough to potentially screw up an already-lucky experiment.

    I have to assume the secondary fermentation saved me from oxidation. Do you typically re-introduce oxygen for a secondary fermentation?

    Another question - I'd like to keep this yeast trub going. Is it a lost cause now that I've introduced fruit? I didn't use a hop bag, so the bits and pieces are just hanging out in the yeast. I've read that harvesting and later creating a starter can mess up the ratio of bugs, so I am hesitant to bother with normal yeast washing techniques.
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.