Doctor Strangematter

Pardon my ignorance, but despite the "hype", I've never heard of this. Who brews it? And what is it?

 

Bottle Logic / It's waxed so it must be a whale. [See Fig Poppa Thread]

 

Isn't this the OC Brew Ha Ha beer this year?

 

All I know is that its a saison.

 

But with no bottle limit and distribution, I wont be able to pull shit with this.

 

Noble?

 

Only if they charged $20+ for it.

 

It's an imperial saison aged in Chardonnay barrels! I'm not too big a fan of chardonnay barrel aged beers usually.

Doesn't seem like too big of a hit on untapped so far (avg around 3.6)

 

Not sure if that was the right crowd to get an accurate read on a saison.

 

Why is that? People that use Untappd are usually only drinking BMC and once in a while get dragged to a brewery to drink craft beer?

 

Uh No? Why would anyone who drinks BMC use Untappd? Congratulations on rushing to judgement and looking like an idiot.

I visit Tustin Brewing on average 2-3 times a week, and the general crowd there isn't going to evaluate a saison like the majority of us would. If you look at the Untappd ratings breakdown on Dr. Strangemater, you'll see exactly that as the majority did not provide a rating at all with the rest giving it mostly 4's or 4.5's. If anything, I'd say this beer right now looks to be much better than the Untappd rating provided earlier and further cement that pulling an Untappd score for a saison with this crowd probably is not the most accurate read.

 

I agree in the fact that it's still too early to judge from a new beer on untapped. But generally... I seem to agree with the general average for most beers on untappd.

 

Why? You implied that Untappd users are not able to make a generalized 1-5 assessment on a beer. All of the ratings came from bottles or people at TBC, yet this is not the "right crowd" in your opinion. lol

In fact looking through the 20+ ratings of it on Untappd, those that rated it gave it 4+ stars except 3 that gave it 3.5 stars.

Why are you so defensive? You work for BottleLogic?

 

If you'd like to first read my response, I either addressed this already or in no way said that ("implied that Untappd users are not able to make a generalized 1-5 assessment on beer").

 

Clearly you don't understand the Untappd rating system. You do seem to know that Untappd users are not capable of evaluating a saison on a scale of 1-5. lol.

 

Let me know, once again, if you want to address my comments and not something you randomly made up. Congratulations on continuing to claim something I never said?

Oh, and I guess it may be relevant to your bizarre claim to know that I'm a heavy Untappd user (4k/2k). But you know, keep listening to your own voices.

 

Does that statement not imply that the 20+ people that rated it don't know how to rate the beer correctly even though the vast majority gave it 4-5 stars which fall in line to your opinion of it?

Don't get all defensive buddy. I just stated that your comment made the assumption that Untappd users don't know what they are doing. Then you called me out an idiot and followed it up with a bunch of rating numbers that actually agree with you even though you said that was not the "right crowd."

 

They tell me to burn things....

 

Simply put, Untapped users will more than likely be tickers. And no ticker is going to be drinking up that BMC stuff.


As for Dr Strange Matter, I'll be in the area to meet up an out of towner for a trade, so that gives me proper justification to pick up a bottle if the price isn't at Noble level, that is.