Never been to either NYC location, but judging by the website of their Flatiron store it doesn't look like much. Are you talking just bottles, or the beer brewed on-site and served in their rooftop restaurant? Here's the current restaurant beverage menu. Decent.
I'm looking more at Bottles. I know there is a Whole Foods a few block away as well that I can run by; but i thought i remember someone saying Eatly had a decent selection of Grimm as well?
I went there once because there were Grimm cans there (according to someone in the Grimm thread here) and they were incredibly overpriced. The rest of the selection was limited and overpriced too. I walked out without buying anything and haven’t been back. It’s more of a foodie place than anything.
Eataly FiDi doesn't have much around besides Grimm, but because of this you can reliably find it there. The Flatiron location has more, but it's usually not any better than a typical bottle shop. As someone who used to try to hunt down Grimm cans on the regular, I'd hear all these stories about $20 4 packs but I have never once seen cans priced below $6/ea. I think Eataly has them for about $7.
Was just there last night picking up some ingredients for dinner. Lots of Dogfish head and bottles of expensive Italian beer. Much better selection at the Whole Foods in Tribeca.
yup that is all i found too and it is not easy to find, Whole Foods was much better for sure. i didnt see many singles or cold bombers at whole foods though
