Dismiss Notice
We're celebrating 10 years of BeerAdvocate magazine with $10 print subscriptions for US residents.

Subscribe now!

Four Firkins

Discussion in 'Midwest' started by ToadiesForCody, Mar 26, 2014.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. gatornation

    gatornation Apr 18, 2007 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    he has been grandfathered in
     
    Chaz likes this.
  2. cmannes

    cmannes Mar 15, 2009 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    So is this the dog pile thread on Four Firkins?

    If I think about how much money I've given Old Chicago for several seriously crappy t-shirts I really fail to see the problem. If you don't like kickstarter/indigogo don't fund anything. If you don't like Four Firkins, don't shop there.

    I'm sure everyone here has intimate knowledge of Four Firkins, their business, and their intentions. And if not, why would anyone make such assumptions? Oh right, because this is BS, err BA.
     
    mjryan likes this.
  3. jera1350

    jera1350 Dec 15, 2007 Minnesota

    Ah, so you're one of the $1000 donators. Which two beers are you going to reserve?
     
    n8opot8o, McRyan and pmccallum86 like this.
  4. hoeg0015

    hoeg0015 Jul 15, 2008 Minnesota

    Yeah, but...you did get food and beer for the money you gave Old Chicago in order to earn that t-shirt, right?
     
  5. gatornation

    gatornation Apr 18, 2007 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    i have had great food and brew at old chicago but they have never asked me for money to expand their chain of stores
     
    PerHops, SipIt, pmccallum86 and 2 others like this.
  6. denali55421

    denali55421 Dec 30, 2010 Minnesota

    Not really the same thing...you received goods and services for that money!
    FF business is to sell beer, they want to sell more of it, and they want even more than the price of beer to make it happen!! This is no different (and no less sleazy) than seat licensing at the new (and future) stadiums in town. you can spend $25 on a 4 pack of BCS, plus $500 for the right to spend that $25....You can find any beer in this area if you really look, and if enough people buy into this you won't be able to find them at FF..seems like a ridiculous business model to me...They're scared of TW (as they should be) and want to expand before they should (according to their bottom line) otherwise they wouldn't be asking for a handout, they'd be selling stock!!!
     
  7. JohnSnowNW

    JohnSnowNW Feb 6, 2013 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    Fair enough...just seemed odd that a Californian was commenting in the Midwest section, in a thread about a small bottle-shop.
     
  8. BrettHead

    BrettHead Sep 18, 2010 Nebraska

    So they haven't actually lost maximum12 as a customer? :D
     
    maximum12 likes this.
  9. manny90

    manny90 Feb 7, 2011 California
    Beer Trader

    Nobody ever moves to a different state...
     
  10. JohnSnowNW

    JohnSnowNW Feb 6, 2013 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    Hence the question.
     
  11. McRyan

    McRyan Jul 25, 2012 Minnesota

    Some solid points here. I assume for most of us our friends and families ask us for beer advice and where to shop and what to drink. I have heard the same response over and over again. "That's just dumb" of them to do. Obivously my friends are no wordsmiths :p.
     
    Ungertaker and BeerGoogler like this.
  12. Ungertaker

    Ungertaker Apr 30, 2010 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    And he's an all-around great guy! Too bad he ditched us for an awesome job in Cali...
     
  13. mkhartnett

    mkhartnett Oct 27, 2010 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    Yeah, your comparison is pretty bad. Old Chicago didn't ask you to give them more money then the normal price of the beer just so they can open another chain. I do like kickstarter/indigogo, but not for what seems to be a chance for them to get money from their customers while providing little in return. If Old Chicago asked you to pay $10 for a $5 beer so they could expand, your comparison would be slightly better. Why make the assumption? Because they did a poor job explaining why they are asking for money from their customers. Also, I don't really blame them for doing this. People clearly will hand over their money out of loyalty or whatever. Good for them. From my stand point, it's not really cool, and so while I still like the store, this tarnishes it some. Plus, I want to know how the hell they managed to get financing but somehow don't have the downpayment? What bank is going to do that?
     
    SipIt and McRyan like this.
  14. mjryan

    mjryan Dec 22, 2007 Minnesota

    I'm trying to figure out why people are so upset about this. I see a small business trying to raise money by using a crowd funding web site. A web site where everyday people listen to a businesses pitch and decide whether or not giving that business money is worth it to them. What's the fucking problem? Should they talk to a bank and get a loan and have to pay interest on it? Why? Why would they do that when that can raise capitol in a different, more equitable way? Seems like a no brainer. It's not like they are breaking the law. They aren't stealing from us. The whole process seems to be above boards. This is all so cornfusing.
     
    cmannes likes this.
  15. mkhartnett

    mkhartnett Oct 27, 2010 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    Equitable way? Errrr, huh? No one has claimed they are breaking a law. No one is claiming they are stealing from anyone. No one is saying what they are doing is not above boards(?). Please put your strawman away.

    Now, they are already going to a bank to get financing. So they will already have a loan and will be paying interest on it. They need to put up a down payment and that's what they are asking for. My argument against this is that if after 6 years of business, they don't have their own $50,000 to put up, then it doesn't seem like a good business model, and why would I think a second store will help them that much. If they do have the $50,000, which I'd guess they do, then they are just asking for money so they don't have to dig in their own pockets. Take the risk away from them. Which I've said, is smart business, getting cheap money is good for them, but as a customer, I'm not giving money for minimal return, zero investment in the company just so they can make more money. If one store does not have a sustainable business model, and yet has been open for 6 years, I'm curious on how this second store will change that.
     
    SipIt, McRyan and maximum12 like this.
  16. maximum12

    maximum12 Jan 21, 2008 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    This is the fourth page of the thread. I bet if you read the first three, you'll be able to figure it out.
     
    BeerGoogler, Ish1, mnbearsfan and 5 others like this.
  17. DBL_Steve

    DBL_Steve Sep 10, 2013 Minnesota

    They are probably seeking the 20% down as required by most lenders on a "commercial" loan. This way they minimize out-of-pocket expense. As far as creating "sustainability"... with a second store comes a second set of expenses relative to operations. Yes, there will be an additional revenue stream but at this point, how much opportunity is still out there? The Woodbury market (and south-east metro) is already saturated with retail and the addition of his store plus two others that are coming (including Total Wine) makes no sense. While time will tell, my guess is there isn't enough busine$$ to sustain additional competitors. And when you factor in how tight things have become in obtaining limited products, they may encounter challenges filling this store in a manner consistent with their other location. If "xyz" brand only ships 30 cases into the state of a given beer, they will not be able to double their allocation from the wholesaler because there isn't any more to give. This is the reality we all face and until the "bubble" we're in subsides, things won't be changing any time soon...
     
  18. McRyan

    McRyan Jul 25, 2012 Minnesota

    https://twitter.com/SchellsDan
     
  19. mnbearsfan

    mnbearsfan Dec 25, 2009 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    I think I will have to buy me some Schmaltz's Alt tomorrow, so nice to find good beer all over the state.

    And since Schells isn't "craft beer" does FF even sell it?
     
    Ungertaker and McRyan like this.
  20. dashycashy

    dashycashy Nov 20, 2010 Minnesota

    Just picked up a 12 pack of saga.
     
  21. McRyan

    McRyan Jul 25, 2012 Minnesota

    Well played. But he RT's Coffee Dad so he is clearly in touch with what the general public likes.
     
  22. Ungertaker

    Ungertaker Apr 30, 2010 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    140 posts to get to a Saga comment?!? That has to be some sort of record for the Midwest forum.
     
  23. hoeg0015

    hoeg0015 Jul 15, 2008 Minnesota

    After discussions with many friends, competitor liquor store employees and owners, and thinking about this from a much larger, community perspective, I have come full circle on this project. you can now countme as a solid, contributing supporter.
     
    psychotia likes this.
  24. OnIowa

    OnIowa May 31, 2011 Iowa
    Beer Trader

    Why would you go to a bank and take out a loan with interest when you can take 5 minutes, post a glorified note on the internet, and have random strangers GIVE YOU MONEY. Nobody is being forced to click "donate." There is a minor return on investment given that you have some advantages as the store afterwards as a donator, but for the most part, it's FREE MONEY. Isn't this every business man's dream? Hell, Goodwill has made a cottage industry out of selling for profit items that they didn't pay for. It's the perfect system if you can get away with it.
     
  25. 4four4

    4four4 Apr 27, 2007 Minnesota

    I just picked up a 6 pack of Miller Lite.
     
  26. AnalogErik

    AnalogErik Jul 23, 2013 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    I was a bit put off by them when I asked if they had any Sucks! left 10 days after release and the guy I talked to only responded with "No, we are a destination store, that never sits on the shelf here".

    So i swung by Byerlys across the highway and bought a case.
     
  27. MCImes

    MCImes Dec 31, 2010 Connecticut

    I like your thinking.

    I tried the new/revamped Horizion red IPA for the first time this week and its not quite as good as I remember. Also, I revisited Rochefort 10. I forgot how delicious this beer is.
     
  28. will1256

    will1256 Dec 4, 2010 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    Difference: Goodwill is an actual charity. Pretty sure a donation to FF is not tax-deductible and will probably do little to help feed starving children or whatever silly social welfare project those scamps over at Goodwill are up to these days.
     
  29. TheBeerDrinker

    TheBeerDrinker Jan 29, 2014 Minnesota

    Incorrect... Goodwill is not a charity. Goodwill takes all your clothes, sells them, and donates none of the money to anybody. HOPE YOU UNDERSTAND AS THERE ARE BETTER CHARITIES.

    I guess I don't care anymore. Either people really like the Firkins and want to support them or they think they are going to get little for lots. They can't think they are going to get much for what they re giving. Let the people give and FF take. That's how it works. People seem to want to donate. Let them if they want to. I can't fault them as I don't know what their reasons for donating are. I certainly would rather spend $1000 there and get beer and they get profits. Some people just have more money than time I guess. Hail the rich. It's not like we are all poor or we would be drinking Natural Ice but some of us (not me) have too much money and need friends or things to feel good about.
     
  30. UnderhillAcct

    UnderhillAcct Mar 29, 2010 Minnesota

    Exactly right. And you aren't required to give money to them. They are up to $18,000+, so other people see things differently. They aren't going to lose $1 in sales because of this.
     
  31. mjryan

    mjryan Dec 22, 2007 Minnesota

    But, but, what about word of mouth? This will be their ruin I tell ya.
     
  32. TheBeerDrinker

    TheBeerDrinker Jan 29, 2014 Minnesota

    I agree but there are always going to be enough people to replace the people who don't shop there unfortunately. People want a craft beer store and they do seem to provide. That being said they are on the other side of town and I have only been there a couple of times. I would rather support the stores who appreciate my business and don't try to take advantage of their notoriety. I would rather support people who have treated me right over the years. It's a handshake type of thing. We support our locals and they know that so they try their best to do the same for us. How can you help your locals who have always supported you when you basically auction the best beers off? It just doesn't make sense. They will survive by forgetting about your support. Let people donate if they are dumb enough to donate. I can see small amounts but unless you are rich you can't afford to and those people are probably gonna get the beers anyway. Unfortunately people will forget about all this. But the other stores that you support will not forget about it. They appreciate your business. Stores can't be all things to all people and neither can consumers. As a consumer I am sure you expect a little respect if you are a regular customer who tries to support the little stores. In the end, it's all about bigger stores, chains, and the mom and pops. I would rather support the mom and pop. They need your support. Walmarts of liquor like FF wants to be and places like Total Wine are not about the normal person. I can tell you Total Wine told me they didn't have something they did even after searching cause they have dummies who don't know their product. I hate when people at a liquor store ask me if I need any help unless I do have a question because 99% of the time I know more than them. It's like going to best Buy and having some little kid try to tell you about stuff they don't know about
     
    #152 TheBeerDrinker, Apr 2, 2014
    Last edited: Apr 2, 2014
  33. will1256

    will1256 Dec 4, 2010 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    Thanks, chain email my grandma sent me. You're wrong, but in any case, I really don't give two $hits about what FF does with their business. If this works well for them, they open their second, third, 500th store, great. It just doesn't sit well with me, but to be honest, I rarely shop there anyway and I don't imagine they're really going to miss the $50 a year I spend there.
     
  34. dasmusik

    dasmusik Oct 25, 2011 Minnesota

    I think its an abusive of people's good will. Ive shopped there before, I probably would have in the future, and now I'm not. They might not be losing $1 in sales TO YOU because of this, but they are to me (and others, by the sound of it). If they don't have the money to put down on their own, aren't willing to seek investors, and instead have to beg from the public, they could probably use all the $1 from the rest of us that they can muster. They probably will be successful with their exploiation in the end, but it doesn't mean we have to be complicit in it or are silly in voicing our disagreement with the business tactics.

    Think of when BMC pushes out the little guys' shelf space in liquor stores- doesn't mean I have to give BMC money by buying it, doesnt mean BMC wont be successful because people see things differently, and BMC sure as hell ont lose any sales because of it. But it sure isn't cool...
     
    SipIt and maximum12 like this.
  35. TheBeerDrinker

    TheBeerDrinker Jan 29, 2014 Minnesota

    That's my understanding of how distributors bully the little stores. They say if you buy a bunch of this shit beer and put up a display then we'll be more likely to give you more of the good beer you want. That's how it works. I've heard it straight from the mouths of store owners. They don't want to have to carry shit beer or at least as much as they are basically forced to but unless they do they won't get much when the distributors are talking at the table about who gets what. It's how things go and don't think it isn't. Unfortunately the more InBev and others buy good breweries the more the bribery goes. Get your head out of the sand. The distributors are like the beer mafia so to speak and they control who gets what. It's reality. Once you realize it you'll be more compassionate for the mom and pop stores who don't have all the latest flavors because they weren't allowed to due to big business. Big business is what screws up most of the other parts of the world and this is no different.
     
  36. evilgenius1917

    evilgenius1917 Feb 16, 2009 Minnesota

    This means nothing without specific examples.
     
    GottaHaveMyHops and Chaz like this.
  37. TheBeerDrinker

    TheBeerDrinker Jan 29, 2014 Minnesota

    I can't go into specific examples without possibly harming the owners of a few shops I know. Take it for what you will. Maybe they make them have a huge bud display when they don't want to sell bud but they are FORCED to do it because they also want to carry beers that their customers want. If you can't understand that then I can't help you out. This sort of stuff happens all the time to smaller businesses and even bigger ones if they want to get certain products. It saddens me to see this as I know they want to carry certain beers that others get but they just can't get them. Comprende? It's not how business should go. They should be able to sell what they want without having to bow down and take up space for shitty beers.
     
  38. TheBeerDrinker

    TheBeerDrinker Jan 29, 2014 Minnesota

    @evilgenius...you have to know this stuff goes on. Do you think I'm some sort of whacko that has no idea how the alcohol business works? You have to know it goes on. Come on. This is just basic corporate business. I hate to bring it to drug terms but there are similarities. The more you sell the cheaper you get things and you get more access to more things. I HATE to use that example but maybe you can understand that. I don't know who you are. I'm sure you are a nice guy. But the two things are very close unfortunately. The more business you do the more free you are to get the better product, etc... I HATE to make the comparison but ..... damn man if you don't understand that then I don't think you will so we should just agree to disagree as I don't think you understand business.
     
    #158 TheBeerDrinker, Apr 2, 2014
    Last edited: Apr 2, 2014
  39. mkhartnett

    mkhartnett Oct 27, 2010 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    Well, that's not factually correct. They will lose some sales. Already know people not wanting to go there. Is it enough to make any sort of impact? No. And yes, they've raised $18,000, and that's basically stalled the last few days. Sure they'll still meet their goal, but after that initial rush, it's pretty much stopped. Luckily for them even if they miss their goal they get to keep the cash.
     
    McRyan likes this.
  40. mkhartnett

    mkhartnett Oct 27, 2010 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    No one has claimed they will be ruined, so please stop with this silliness.
     
    maximum12 and McRyan like this.
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  • About Us

    Your go-to website for beer (since 1996), publishers of BeerAdvocate magazine (since 2006) and hosts of world-class beer events (since 2003). Respect Beer.
  • Extreme Beer FestĀ® Cometh

    February 3-4, 2017. Boston, Mass. Limited tickets available. Prepare for epicness.

    Learn More
  • 10 Years of BeerAdvocate Magazine

    We're celebrating 10 years of BA mag with $10 print subscriptions for US residents!

    Subscribe