Your best bet is in Blacklick. Its called Blacklick wine and spirits. It is on Broad St between Reynoldsburg/New Albany rd and Waggoner Rd, Joe is the beer guy there and is awesome. Also the Giant Eagle on Hamilton and Morse has a surprisingly good selection.
There used to be a store down at the intersection of 62 and Morse rd by the Donatos and Hoggys. I know cuz I once bought out their last 2 cases of GL Christmas Ale. It's been a while, but its not far from where you're at.