Can I dislike it more than once? Enjoy By is one of my favorite beers hands down. Nugget Nectar is a very solid beer also, but not in the same category. Also, the person who said HF earlier, BLASPHEMOUS! Kidding, but I can't see it. Every beer by them is one of the best I've had for each style. For me, I think recently it was Pliny. When I first had it I was like oh wow. Then a year later a few weeks ago having it on tap at Monk's in Philly I was underwhelmed (then got a 750 of Iris, made up for it). Pliny is a well brewed beer, but it is not a mind blower Not that it wasn't, but today with everyone taking a stab at that style, there's going to be better. So for that beer to still be so highly rated is beyond me.