I have a firestone walker PNC and have been thinking about trading it for something nice. Could it fetch a 13' backyard rye? What else? What would you trade a for a PNC?
I have some PNC already because it's one of my favorite BA stouts, but just gave up a Cantillon Iris for another one. I think I can actually go and buy one at the local bar here, which I'll probably do when it's back on draft again for Philly Beer Week soon. When it was difficult to get, I gave up an Abraxas + Berserker for one. I just sent one to Chicago so a trade partner out there can proxy a trade for me for a Proprietor's. I've traded it before for Proprietor as well, but also to another repeat trade partner. The point is, it can trade well with the right person. Quite frankly, 1:1 for a Backyard now isn't a bad trade, but the Backyard side should at least add something to even out $4$. Good luck!
I would hold the PNC higher than the rye. PNC is better in taste, higher in price, and lower in bottle count.