ISO: PTY x5 FT: Maman ‘19

looking like maman about 225~ and pty~175 not sure where 5:1 makes sense. let me know if u interested in making a deal at the current going rate

 

Haven’t run out yet .....either day and huge lines....great offer—-but wait it out....

 

5:1 !? Lol

 

Where are you seeing pty at 175? Have seen it in FB groups around 65-75

 

MBC, so questionable around legitimancy. Also, sbvg has people quoting that 2 closed for a lot b but I have not been able to find the original post.

 

only in 2020 do malt bomb ipa's trade for top tier stouts.

 

What’s going to end up happening is no is going to enjoy these beers because people will haggle to much and then by the time someone does make a trade it won’t be as fresh. I don’t get the negativity around these trade offers. On Ig someone posted $80 and I believe no one has taken him on his offer. The difference with ptyis that it’s only offered once a year and you can’t cellar the bottles , you have to drink sooner than later.

 

never had PTY but if it’s anything like Elder than i’m sure it’s beyond solid and a breath of fresh air from the NE-style IPAs that flood the market today. that said, all hops should pretty much be $4$ trades. #justsaynotowhaleipas

 

I can tell you it varies greatly year to year and keg to keg. I've had it times and it being amazing and other times just not worth waiting in line for 1.5 hrs at a bar only to spend $12 on an 8 ounce pour. It is hands down the best west coast triple IPA even on the not so great kegs so yes If you're in search for non NE style, you won't be disappointed.... unless someone sits on their bottles for 3 weeks before trading them.

 

2 per. And they are waiting 8hrs

 

Location checks out

 

The time a person chooses to wait for beer has zero weight in trading. Nor does travel time. The fact that it’s a 7 hour round trip to Hill Farmstead for me never factors into negotiations. If I mentioned that in a trade I’d expect the other person to tell me to get fucked.

 

Kind of, difficulty and availability impact someone’s willingness to trade. Lots of things drive people to spend too much on beer. Quality, investment, style, on tap (already tried), it’s from St. Louis ;-). Man made his offer, easy enough to just ignore it if I don’t agree.

 

I’m not responding to/disagreeing with the offer one way or another. I wasn’t replying to OP. I’m responding to a person who suggested they are waiting 8 hours for the beer (to trade or otherwise) as a factor in its “worth.” That’s their choice. That doesn’t factor in a negotiation imo. Can I quote my gas money in a trade negotiation?

 

Don’t let @Rustytacos hear that. Apparently I was wrong for having the same opinion as you...

 

Hell of an offer @gcamparone good luck!!

 

Exactly...The value will keep going down because of the shorter shelf life. Most of us, myself included, want to just try it just to tell our friends we've had it.

 

Should my wife be worried or should take as a compliment that you think about me?