I am ISO WC. Period. I'm offering Darkness, Backwoods Bastard, NG fruits, Bells, my cellar list and quite a bit more. I have gotten a few trades and even some negative feedback regarding the trade value of Darkness. This year Darkness again went fo $20 at Darkness Day. I did not get the pleasure to wait in line and have paid $25 for my Darkness for trade. If you waited in line for your beer and I didn't I would give in for the $5. Its not about the money. It's about what is fair. I'll take a hit... but just looking for WC. I have offered a bit. Even said 3 WC for 9 Fruits with more NG and a '14 Darkness as a bonus to get it done. So the discussion regards two things. The truth behind Darkness pricing... and what is fair to get WC. I'm a PS member but can still only buy so much WC. Suggestions please! Seriously.... I am looking for WC.
Based on the list you posted you are offering seasonal/limited shelf beers for a brewery only beer. 2012 WC is batch 1 IIRC and was the smallest batch so who knows how much is left floating around FT. Maybe offer some more limited/brewery only beers or go way over $4$. Good luck.
