Outside Growlers BS in NC

Discussion in 'South Atlantic' started by wsdang, Jan 21, 2015.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. wsdang

    wsdang Initiate (0) Oct 12, 2012 North Carolina

    What is with the BS stories from establishments that refuse to fill outside growlers? By outside growlers, I mean glass growlers with labels from a different establishment or unlabeled DrinkTank stainless steel growlers. Over the last year or so I have had a growing number of pubs and breweries in both Asheville and Winston-Salem refuse to fill them. That's a little disconcerting given that the 2013 law and subsequent rule change was supposed to spur growler sales. I do think its a shame that places chose to limit their growlers sales. Given the ever-growing number of choices out there and the large number of growlers I already own, I am more likely to frequent places that fill outside growlers.

    My bigger concern is the BS stories I keep hearing. "We can't fill your growler because its against the law"...not any more. "We can't wash the growler and the law requires it"...then how do you wash your pint glasses. "We don't have the equipment to re-label your growler"...you don't have a pen and a tag. The worst was "The law only allows us to prefill"...this came from a non-brewery pub and the rules specifically prohibit establishments that don't have brewing licenses from prefilling. Why give all of these BS answers? Just say "we choose not to fill outside growlers".

    BTW...I am not on some sort of crusade here. I didn't name any of the places that turned down outside growlers. When I ask for a growler fill and get turned down, I typically just say " oh...is there a problem with the growler?". I don't start arguments with the wait staff.
     
    GreysonDaniels and fehrminator like this.
  2. pimpinmidget

    pimpinmidget Initiate (0) Mar 20, 2012 North Carolina

    what places in Winston will not fill them?
     
  3. cronimi

    cronimi Aspirant (292) Jan 28, 2009 North Carolina

    I think it's more likely the establishments -- and the people behind the bar to whom you're speaking -- don't understand the new law. But you may be right.
     
  4. wsdang

    wsdang Initiate (0) Oct 12, 2012 North Carolina

    @pimpinmidget...not trying to stir up anything against any place. Places in Winston where I have personally filled outside growlers include Foothills, City Beverages, Stella Brew, Lowes and Whole Foods. I think Hoots and Small Batch also fill outside growlers but I have't personally tried myself. In Asheville it seems worse. Several breweries and pubs turned down outside growlers. LAB (Lexington Avenue Brewery) was the exception. They cheerfully filled up my DrinkTank and even gave me some extra stickers to decorate it.
     
  5. mbbransc

    mbbransc Initiate (0) Mar 24, 2009 North Carolina

    CLT breweries won't fill outside growlers. They told me it was against the law too. I told them that law has changed and got the 'we only swap out growlers' story. I finished my pint and left . Whataya gonna do? I certainly don't need any more growlers. I don't have room for all of the ones I have!

    I haven't had that problem anywhere in WS. Bestway won't fill non-Bestway growlers.
     
    KhakCane likes this.
  6. GreysonDaniels

    GreysonDaniels Initiate (0) Feb 10, 2012 North Carolina

    I completely agree. I for one think that the breweries a) want to make money on the growler purchase itself b) want the free marketing of you having the growler. Another common ridiculous excuse I've heard is "what if you take this ABC Brewing growler to a party and everyone loves the beer, but we here at XYZ Brewing filled it and they won't know its our beer" Thats why I typically bring a Greens Bev growler so I can say that its not another brewery's growler.
     
    KhakCane likes this.
  7. tlh1005

    tlh1005 Initiate (0) Oct 1, 2009 North Carolina

    How do shops fill outside growlers and insure that the transfer is sanitary? Do they always use a tube and sanitize it after each use?
     
  8. stdaniel

    stdaniel Initiate (0) Apr 10, 2014 North Carolina

    How do shops fill inside growlers and insure that the transfer is sanitary? Most in house glass is taken straight from the box to the tap without any sanitizing. I'd say that my ability to wash my reusable growler is at least as good if not better than one that comes straight out of the box.

     
  9. MrPeabodysBeard

    MrPeabodysBeard Initiate (0) Aug 8, 2010 North Carolina

    Just to throw something out here....As a retail shop, when the law was passed, in that law it was required of us to wash and sanitize all growlers before they were to be filled (a part of the law pushed through predominantly by breweries that wanted to make sure their product was sent out the way they intended), and we are required to label the growlers with certain required information. I would imagine this is where you are coming into an issue, with shops and breweries. Most won't fill other growlers, because that would require you, the customer, waiting while they cleaned, sanitized, and dried your growler. This is the "it's against the law" comment that your getting from people, as opposed to the long drawn out reason. I only fill our growlers, however I will clean and sanitize a growler if the person is willing to wait 20 minutes or so while it dries, most won't, but it IS in fact a law and that is the comments that you are getting. And I am not sure about other places but all of our glass is cleaned and sanitized as we pull it fresh out of the box before we fill it....I wouldn't just drink out of a pint glass that came off of a store shelf, and I wash my underwear before I wear it when I bring it home from the store!! Hope this helps with your frustration

    Chris
     
  10. NoMoreBeerBelly

    NoMoreBeerBelly Pundit (825) Dec 2, 2009 North Carolina

    Huh? You popping tags at the thrift store for your drawers? :stuck_out_tongue:


    As for the drying thing...why does it need to dry? Wash, dunk in san star (or whatever you guys use), wait a minute, rinse, dump, papertowel outside, fill. That is what I do with my homebrew kegs and growlers (that I fill from my own kegerator). No need to dry (unless that is the law).
     
    MrPeabodysBeard likes this.
  11. stdaniel

    stdaniel Initiate (0) Apr 10, 2014 North Carolina

    Growler Grlz in Durham does a fantastic job with outside growlers. Of course, they are set up completely for growler fills (and pints). If you bring in an outside growler, they will run it through a quick wash cycle, compressed air dry, san star rinse, compressed air dry and then fill. Start to finish it's less than 5 minutes and encourages one to buy a pint. Win/win from this consumer's perspective.

    That said, not all bars/breweries/groceries are set up to be quite as efficient, obviously.
     
    brstls4drmrs likes this.
  12. MrPeabodysBeard

    MrPeabodysBeard Initiate (0) Aug 8, 2010 North Carolina

    Don't you judge me by where I buy my underpants!!:grinning:
    Yeah...I bought a little much on the sanitizer that I use, it's one of the commercial grade, strip the top layer of skin off kind of stuff....still trying to get rid of the 5 gallon buckets that I bought! However you are correct a dip in San-star won't have to be completely dry....but still has to be done
     
  13. MrPeabodysBeard

    MrPeabodysBeard Initiate (0) Aug 8, 2010 North Carolina

  14. wsdang

    wsdang Initiate (0) Oct 12, 2012 North Carolina

    Actually I have had less issues at stores and more issues at pubs. My understanding of the law is that it requires the establishment to clean the growler using methods similar to those already used by pubs to clean their bar glasses (ie 3 sinks or dish washer). The sad part is these pubs are actually losing out on sales. If I walk into a pub and they tell me it will take 10-20 minutes to fill my growler then I order a pint while I wait. By saying no, they lose the pint sales plus the growler fill sale. ...and potentially future business...
     
  15. andyctree

    andyctree Zealot (663) Apr 20, 2010 North Carolina

    If I had to wait 20 minutes to buy a growler I wouldn't so they would actually be losing money from me.

    I have no problem with the law or breweries interpretation of it. I always bring a labeled growler to the places I visit in Asheville and if i go somewhere else I either cough up the money for one of their growlers or don't buy one.
     
    Woodrow and rgordon like this.
  16. tlh1005

    tlh1005 Initiate (0) Oct 1, 2009 North Carolina

    I guess what I am getting at is that I have seen places fill growlers before without washing them... granted more so before the new laws, but I've still seen it. I didn't know if there was something they were doing that could some how make this sanitary and I just missed it or didn't know about it (but that something certainly wasn't washing).
     
  17. McAndrew

    McAndrew Savant (1,004) Jun 12, 2013 North Carolina
    Trader

    ** If growler grlz wasn't a complete rip-off and if they counter pressured their growler fills then it would be a slam dunk**
    Once Glass Jug (Durham) opened and set their prices to more reasonable rates I was sold. Ohh and they counter pressure your beer so it'll stay MUCH fresher longer than the no pressured treated growlers.
     
  18. treznor

    treznor Pooh-Bah (1,814) Dec 20, 2006 North Carolina
    Pooh-Bah Trader

    What I've seen a couple of places do (and it could be more widespread and I just haven't seen it) is they'll take a case of growlers, sanitize them and the caps, let them dry, put the cap back on and then store them that way. Then when they need to fill a growler they just open it up and fill, already sanitized. If the place was storing their sanitized growlers in the case they came in, it certainly could look like they were just pulling them from the case and filling them.
     
  19. stdaniel

    stdaniel Initiate (0) Apr 10, 2014 North Carolina

    I get the idea of counter pressure filling, but I've never had problems with regular fill growlers. Then again, I don't intend to keep them for more than a few weeks.

    I definitely like what Glass Jug is doing, but they just aren't getting the volume of good beer (mostly Wicked Weed) that Growler Grlz does.

     
  20. musicmax

    musicmax Initiate (157) Jun 21, 2014 North Carolina
    Trader

    The "wash and sanitize" requirement doesn't explain why an establishment won't refill an outside growler. I could buy a growler from Bob's Brewery, take it home, drink it, bring it back (presumably dirty) to Bob's and Bob would refill it, whereas Bob won't refill a growler from Jim's Brewery, or even worse an unmarked growler.

    I was just at Wicked Weed in Asheville yesterday and they refused to fill my flip-top (gasket) growler and instead forced me to buy their screw top one. Duckworth's also forces you to use theirs (also screw top - bought an Ommegang Quad that went flat within two days). In Charlotte, OMB allows you to trade in your unmarked flipper for their prefilled (and presumably counter-pressured) ones. Sugar Creek will fill yours. Bottle Shop will too, but you have to have the state's health disclaimer notice on a tag or a sticker. Beer Growler on South Blvd. will fill yours, as will Total Wine.
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.