Top Five Coffee Beers

1. BCBCS
2. Terrapin WNB
3. KBS
4. Beer Geek Speedway
5. FBS

 

1. Mornin' Delight
2. Surly Four
3. Last Snow
4. Maple Bacon Coffee Porter
5. Surly Coffee Bender

I am also mentioning Bourbon County Coffee and HF Genology of Morals, but not including them on the list because the OP said non-barrel aged coffee beers. So these two would have made the #3 and #4 spots on the list.

 

FBS
Burlington Beer- Barista
HF- Earl
Trillium- PM Dawn
Trillium- Pot & Kettle w/coffee

 

That I've tried, in no order

BCBCS
Modern Times - Black House
Smog City - Groundwork Coffee Porter
Ballast Point - Victory At Sea
Founders - Breakfast Stout

 

Surly Coffee Bender and Bent Paddle Cold Press are both great ones.

Behind those two, it's harder to say... Probably FBS, Lagunitas Cappuccino, and Victory at Sea.

 

1. MBCP
2. Last Snow
3. BCBCS
4. Sump
5. Coffee Bender

 

+1 on the Bent Paddle Cold Press Black Ale.

 

I just had Pizza Boy's Sunny Side Up (little amps coffee) and I would put that at the top for me. Great mouthfeel and a perfect blend of coffee and chocolate. A+

BCBCS just edges it out for my #1 spot

 

Surly 4
Bent Paddle Cold Press
Surly Coffee Bender
TG Mornin Delight
Bell's Java Stout

 

In my opinion the two best come from St. Louis.

1. Perennial Sump
2. Schlafly Coffee Stout

There are others, but I chose those for their simplicity. They are great beers with the addition of coffee. Xocoveza, Coffee Abraxas, Bible Belt, are great beers with coffee in them, but i wouldn't call them coffee stouts.

 

Péché Mortel and Tweak, 10 way tie for most of the others above - really like this style of beer.

 

Goose Island BCBCS
Funky Buddha
Maple Bacon Coffee Porter
Founders KBS
Peche Mortel
Founders Breakfast Stout

Honorable mentions to Jacks Abby BA Coffee Framinghammer, Ballast Point Victory at Sea, Stone Espresso IRS, & Terrapin Wake N Bake

 

(My homebrew) Oatmeal Coffee Stout
Toppling Goliath -Morning Delight
Surly -Coffee Bender
Tyranena -Down N Dirty stout
Founders- Breakfast stout
Central Waters -Brewhouse Coffee Stout

 

Tree House Double Shot
Dieu Du Ciel Peche Mortel
To Ol Goliat
Cellarmaker Imperial Coffee & Cigarettes
Stone Dayman

 

1- Goose Island Bourbon County coffee
2- Alesmith BAVSS
3- Alesmith VSS
4- Central Waters Peruvian Morning.
5- Stone expresso IRS.
Obviously if maple would have been allowed TG- Mornin' Delight and Tree House Good Morning would jump right up near the top of the list.

 

I guess from bottom to top, just for coffee flavors alone and not really overall beer or style preference.

Sam's Coffee IPA OHB (I could not believe an IPA and coffee flavors went together but this one really stood out!)
BCBCS
MBCP
Big Bad Baptist
KBS

 

Bourbon County Coffee Stout
Avery Tweak
Carton Regular Coffee
FBS
Victory At Sea

Brunch Weasel just narrowly missed the list. Quite an amazing beer, just had it for the first time on a trip to Bangkok at the Mikkeller Bar there.

I know that FBS and VaS have some additional stuff going on, but they're both amazing enough in my opinion to bend the rules for a bit.

 

Has anyone tried the Death Wish Coffee IPA from Saratoga? I wasn't able to get my hands on any and was wondering how it was...

 

Founder's Breakfast stout
Coronado's Blue Bridge Coffee stout (highly underrated IMO & their best)
DFH Chicory Stout
Bell's java stout
Troegs java head

 

Caffe Americano
JBM Speedway
Sump
Big Bad Baptist
Founders Breakfast Stout