Trade feedback needs to be fixed?

You should probably contact a Moderator.

Maybe post in the Support/Requests thread:
https://www.beeradvocate.com/community/forums/support-requests.33/

 

Looks like a miscommunication? Only @Todd can change feedback and he'll need a lot more details to determine what action(s) to take.

 

Gotta be honest, I don't even know what his feedback means.

I saw you linked a tiny part of your conversation. Having seen this happen before, context is important, so you're going to need to send the entire conversation if a moderator takes this up.

Lastly, did you reach out to @dell19 to see if you could come to an amiable resolution? That's always much better than dragging the authorities into a trading issue.

 

tbh I think you misunderstood the thread.
https://www.beeradvocate.com/community/threads/ft-bcbs-knob-creek-iso-bcbs-prop.546969/
OP posted offering Knob Creek then dell19 offered coffee for it. You vaguely posted 2 coffees for reserve. Seeing he had offered coffee I would think he was sending the coffee for reserve too.
Always best to be horribly pedantic while setting up the trade and assume nothing.
for example YOU: 'I send you coffee you send reserve? is that right?'
HIM: either 'yes' - or 'no I have the coffee and wanted Reserve'
Split the cost of shipping it back both post neutrals and learn to be VERY VERY pedantic about stating EVERYTHING when setting up a trade.

 

Look at your response, you didnt elaborate who was sending what and he had just posted offering coffee. But JMHO as an outsider reading it. We all learn when we make mistakes, been there done that. Sorry to hear this one didnt work for you. No judgement.

 

@narddawg314 I hate to pile on, but I wholeheartedly agree with @Janeinma . You're just as much at fault as the other person. If it was me, I would not purge the feedback as it is 100% not clear that the trade you intended to make was the one you two were agreeing on, and neither of you stated explicitly what the trade completely. I'm a perfect world, I agree you both deserve neutral feedback (probably).

Live and learn.

 

For sure. As the poster above stated, pedantic is good. I literally (almost always) say: so that I am clear, you are sending: xxx, I am sending: yyyy.

Where do you see that Dell did this a second time? From looking at his feedback, the only thing i see is that he accidentally shipped a Christmas bomb instead of BA Christmas bomb, and to make up for the error, he sent an AB Noir along with the BA Christmas bomb as an apology.

Did I miss it someplace?

 

All this talk with @dell19 involved. I feel he should be tagged just so this isn't a one sided argument.

 

Looking back at that thread, what an absolute mess. @eppie82 nailed it, just message the OP directly if you want to trade with them. If either of you or both of you did that, it would have likely eliminated all of this. Instead you overtook the OPs thread by replying with offers. Then there was another user who jumped in on the action. Wild stuff.

 

@maximum12 actually did above towards the start.

 

It seems to me that both of you mixed up the trade here.
It looks like you left him negative feedback first. So you are complaining that he did the same thing you did?