Trade Value Thread (2019)

I would like to try for a Cantillon lou pepe gueuze (any year), but Im not sure if I have what it takes. Was thinking FO b4 + de Garde Peach (cognac) + Coconut B bomb. Am I in the ball park? Maybe I need to switch out with more sour/wild ales in the offer? Always appreciate the help!

 

Honestly, I think you're way over. LPG isn't quite in the same stratosphere as LPF, and especially LPK.

I'd like to think Peach Cognac itself is pretty close, maybe with FOb4 as plus.

 

That is very helpful and nice to know! I think ill try your suggestion and go from there.

 

Following the cantillon trend here. Just acquired a bottle of however improbable from bottle logic. Any ideas on trade value with respect to cantillon seasonals / limited? Would really like to obtain fou foune or lpf

 

Should be able to get Fou I would think. Probably need a plus for LPF

 

I’ve got a couple of non-public release Hill bottles so kind of tough to figure their value... Damon el Desarollo and 2016 Double Barrel Damon. Would either pull something like a KBBS or Derivation?

 

Would ac ba fudge bucket w vanilla and karma swirl pull a maman 18? Would I still need a plus like a FOb4 or Horus territory?

 

Would a Bramble Rye and 2018 Vanilla bcbs land a BG&E from this most recent release?

 

Yep I would agree. Nath or Fou is a get, would probably need to add for LPG and even probably St lam with how small the yield was this year.

 

I would agree. It may be tough to trade this year variants for it since they were distributed pretty well other than prop and reserve.

 

I posted earlier but I just noticed I wrote it it wrong. Was looking for Maman and was thinking ac ba fudge bucket and ba henna karma and maybe a small plus on my end would so it?

 

I think that's close with the FOb4 realm plus. What helps your side is limited-ish bottles from different regions, Midwest-South-West.

 

Was wondering about the Virginia trade scene namely The Answer. Has anyone done anything recently for any of their crazy fruit shake or higher rated non BA stouts and what it takes?

 

So I really need to knock Morning Delight off the list. Been offering Prop 18’ and BCBSV or Prop 18’ and FOb4 for a MDb5 but just got crickets. Do I really need to add a plus?

 

I think you might have better luck presenting a list like I did giving up rare 15 and rusty nail. I wish I could have kept my rare but if you gotta tick..... throw a list out with a 2-3. Unfortunately too much FOb4 was made and it pales in comparison to FOb3. I've been told the b3 is better than the b1 now.

 

I traded both my md’s from the release away pretty quick and regretted it. Since getting more the day after kbbs I’ve been a lot pickier on what I’m looking for in exchange. I agree you should put out a list of options and be open to discussing when you find someone with a bottle to spare. I don’t think you are off by much value-wise but maybe just provide a couple bottle options to sub in

 

Thanks for the input. I actually did drop a list on Tuesday night in the limited trade thread but still nothing. Thinking ppl are just holding onto them.