Trade Value Thread (2020)

Appreciate the feedback, you're always insightful. I had to post this as I wasn't sure if the (what I also thought were) low offers had anything to do with lack of interest in GoD.

 

Given their current ratings yes they should be 1:1 but I know CA traders have an uphill battle here.

 

Thanks. There's been interest and I wish I could have got up there 2 Friday's ago. 300 bottles limit 1pp. I love Monkish just never get up there bc of it being LA and you have to combat the worst traffic to get to that part of LA. It looks like their best BA release and if people were rating it super high from the first tap only release not knowing Monkish was going to eventually have bottles, you know there weren't just a bunch of people pre hyping at all.

 

I would be happy with a 1:1 on this and am on the Veil side of things but dude is asking for a plus, specifically Starve C. I think thats a bit steep. He is offering a few cans on his side to even things out but I still think Starve C is a bit of an ask for a plus in this instance. Am I wrong in this or is the Ancient Futures bottle being overvalued?

 

Does Maman 19 pull 2020 IWAAD, I Let My Tape Rock, and Thrilla in Manilla? Or does the Maman side need to add. Have no idea where current J wakefield stouts are trading.

 

Ancient Futures is not even overvalued. This trader is a joke if he's asking a starve C as a plus. The ancient futures should need a plus just for starve C. You're fine. Ancient futures was sampled at the same time as GoD and GoD was favored heavily.

 

What kind of plus do I have to add? Looking to get Westly + West Ashley for my DB BCBS. Prefer most recent vintages of both

 

and for the love of Dionysus make sure to provide a tracking number.

 

This is kinda where I was at with things as well. I really appreciate the help

 

Lol. Funniest thing I've heard all week.

 

I would imagine you'd have to add. But don't think a ton. Even it out $4$?

 

I'm thinking westly db 1:1 so mid range plus? 2 year reserve or as much as prop 19?

 

Has anyone drank a Prop ‘14 recently? I haven’t had one for a couple of years so I’m wondering how it’s holding up. It’s one of our favorite beers so I may have to get my hands on one for our first anniversary coming up.

If it’s still drinking well, is anyone moving them anymore? What would it take?

 

Surprisingly cinnnamony still. Didn't seem 6 years old, to me.

 

Hello -

It’s been a minute since I’ve been on the site and haven’t traded in a while. With that said are we discussing strictly beer or can I ask about PVW...

I’m getting married in a month and a half and want to land a bottle for my brothers for the wedding. Admittedly I don’t really drink anymore but thought it would be cool for them to have.

PVW 15 and up. If we’re talking VRU, how many are we talking? Any insight would be appreciated.

 

Without bourbon tax it'd probably be 5 VRU for PVW15, with bourbon tax I'd guess 6-7.

 

Regarding the pvw15, i'd add that you would likely need a really nice anchor, and even so you likely would have to go over "trade value". Without a solid anchor, you could offer 10 vru's of beer and it may or may not close

 

Can someone quantify bourbon tax.

 

The way i look at bourbon tax is that a bottle of whisky can cost $200+ while most beers don't exceed $40 - so even if the beer & bourbon have the same "trade value" the beer side ultimately has some catching up to do based simply on the cost of the whisky.

I could be wrong...

 

no