Trade Value Thread (2020)

It is a 5:3 or a 6:3+literally 2 cans. In my mind it read quite easily but that never seems to convey (according to the Mrs).

Do you think AdF is out of reach here with this offer?

 

I had the first two batches of p4p. Huge differences. That's why I bought the second batch. I drank them fresh both times , so I can't comment how it holds up afrer weeks or so.

If I wasn't overloaded with ipas, I'd get this 3rd batch.

To be honest, I didn't think I was going to care for it.

It's definitely pricey, but it's a few bucks more expensive than typical special releases. I wouldn't spend 7 a can forever, but on occasions totally. In addition, I don't have to drive far away to acquire it.

 

What whiskey level can I get a CocoVibes B3 at?

 

With a bbt3 how far away am I for a OFBB?

 

Probably like level 2

 

Now define Level 2

 

Really want to land an ETL for a special occasion.
Seems like it’s getting harder to get. What is a realistic secondary value? Can I do it with multiple mid level bottles...(Fuzzy, Atrial, etc) or do I really need a solid stout anchor or something like that? What about trading up with a bourbon anchor like OWA or Yama 12? See people post iso etl a lot, but no idea if they’re closing or not.
Thanks

 

I think that’s definitely the snag.

 

I don't know why Elmer is so hyped on this site in particular, really seems like half the iso whiskey is for Elmer. I feel like you're always gonna have better odds trading whiskey for whiskey - Yama 12 is a pricey bottle, cost is almost Elmer secondary - I think someone would take you up on that

 

You would think, but I posted it and didn’t get a single reply

 

I know the feeling. I have what I think is a decent list of stuff for trade, and really am just kinda looking for any offers that might work out. But I get surprisingly few messages/offers. I just want to haggle damnit!

 

Outside of the beltway, Yama 12 sits on shelves. ETL on the other hand has people lined up before the store opens. $38 at VA ABC and a low $175 secondary. You may get some interest with the OWA plus some sours. I would buy a bottle of Blanton's or ECBP, both are better than ETL imo.

 

I've never seen Yama 12 on the shelf for retail ~ $125, but definitely agree there are far far far better bottles than Elmer that are way more accessible. It's a great $40-50 bottle, hell maybe even upwards of $80-90, but anything over that and you're a fucking moron. Don't know why it trades at the level it does other than scarcity and hype

 

Yama is on the shelf in PA state stores for $125....I’m starting to think I should forget about Elmer and target another bottle for celebratory purposes

 

Does Fundamental Theorem need a plus for Meditatio or GoD b2?

 

This one may require some Facebook digging, which I don't have, but has anyone seen the following two bottles trade in recent months (years?)?

Barrel-aged Behemoth (Willet barrels) '17 by 3Floyds
Barrel-aged Behemoth (Woodford barrels) '17 by 3Floyds.

I was going to offer Pulling Nails #11 for both, but I'm just not sure if anyone even has the beers I'd be looking for (let alone the value).

 

We might need to establish where nilla is sitting at...

Anyone?

 

Could batch 2, 2014, A Deal with the Devil, get a Derivation? Specific blends that it would fall in line with value wise? Thanks.

 

How far is BAAT from cbc Maman? What level plus is needed?

 

I did some looking on FB yesterday, and these two have not seemed to move much. I think you are there trade value wise (most posts I saw were selling the behemoths), but could be hindered if there are just not that many out in the wild.