Trade Value Thread (2020)

Any ideas on things Barrel Aged Coffee Shop Vibes is going for?

 

Agree with this completely. The other issue with Rye BBT specifically was how few bottles made it to public sale and the inability to drink on-site. Last year I got a BBT3 and was able to trade it because I got to try it on-site several times. Since I am unsure whether I will have another chance to drink Rye BBT I chose to drink mine. I know a lot of St.Louis guys who have done the same. The bottles I have seen traded have gone for bourbon or trades with big beers as anchors. I think you will have to over-trade to try this beer now. If the beer becomes available for on-site consumption once the pandemic ends you may see a second wave of trades at a lower price of entry.

For the price I think CBC maman is an equally worth non-adjunct StL stout that is currently trading for 1/2-2/3 the price of Rye BBT. I know some people have maligned it recently, but I thought it was better than TWCP Maman.

 

Approximately 2 Rare 15's.

If you haven't had it it is worth drinking. Especially if you just purchased it for a $110 beer package. I dislike coffee stouts and I thought this was phenomenal. I would be hard pressed to think of another beer that is more worthy, especially after adding up the cost you paid.

 

Looking for insight on the Hill Farmstead beers. Would a Central Waters Rye Black Gold cover for one Anna Blueberry and a few cans Ephraim or am I way off?

 

I will agree with Baback. Just don't understand the hate for CBC Maman. It was excellent.

 

With the Black Gold packages, was it limited to one package/ticket per person? Or could you end up buying more to get more rye?

Either way, I think this is more than reasonable. Unannounced limits even on these limited hill bottles has been a case. So, if someone loaded up on Anna Blue and even though Ephraim was a 2, 4-pack limit, seems fair for both sides.

 

BG was 1 pp.

 

Completely agree however the long pole in the tent is finding someone to trade the HF

 

Anyone have any insight to Floodland trading? I know this is kind of a broad ask but I am trying to narrow down what kind of bottles (or what tier bottles) are needed to land something like Seekers After Light or Honey Punch or Collins Family?

 

Right. The more I think about it l, I might be misinterpreting how people who are making the trips are buying. I figured with these high allotments that people would be able to satisfy themselves/friends then turn around and trade for other interesting beers. I’m not making the trips, been almost a year, so I’m pretty dry when it comes to Hill on hand. If I were, I’d make this deal (I love Cw stouts/barrel program) and others I've seen posted.

 

Thank you for this! I lucked into a package today somehow (need proxy help if anyone is willing! Will be generous with a thank you box!) - I am dying to try it ... I have some huge long time wants that I was wondering what it would take to land with this in the mix (SR-71, BBT, I’d like to drink Handjee again, BA Angry Chair, etc ...) — so that was more my point in the post. No idea how this fella trades ‍♂️

 

To be honest with you, don't think this bottle has a ton of value at the moment. It's not going to get higher. I'd say Baback was spot on with 2x rare 15. Possibly lower. I'd drink it, because that alone or even as an anchor is not gonna attract SR, Handjee, BBT, etc. Maybe BA AC?

 

Someone can correct me if I'm wrong but typical BA AC asks are baigccs and BAAT...I think he'd have to add for both but one a bigger add than the other.

BA pbm might be 1:1 or maybe pbm needs to add.

Not sure what other AC ask for regularly

 

Definitely add for BA AT, maybe small plus on his side for BA cupcake?

 

What is the rough value of Jester Kings Atrial Rubicite?
Would would standard Russian River / SARA offerings work? Or is it a once-yearly super rare release? I honestly don’t know anything about it. (Other than it looks delicious).

 

It is a yearly release. 2020 Atrial Rubicite was packaged in 750ml bottles ($35) and 1.5L bottles ($75) with purchase limits of 12 bottles and one bottle per person There were 5,450 750ml bottles and 301 1.5L bottles available to be purchased. 2019 was released in 500ml bottles so the value is gonna vary depending on the year. I can't give you any secondary info but there is the MSRP for whatever that is worth

 

I have seen Honey punch for around 1.5-1.75 rare 15’s I believe seekers to be a little higher 1.75 to 2 the rest I am not sure on.... hard to gauge don’t see a lot move but seekers is excellent IMO

 

That mounds rye sounds amazing btw. Still waiting to see more reviews on the North Park Beer. I think there's just way too many CA traders out there throwing away great beer for whatever. Myself included throwing down the better BL beers for Treehouse. I just don't see a lot of Missouri traders looking for CA beers bc they know they can pick up shelf sours and people will trade their higher end BL beers or decent MT beers for them. It messes up the supply/demand equation huge. That being said Rye BBT is approaching that TWCP Maman status. You haven't thrown this out for any year regular BBT with any success? I mean jeez you're throwing down more than $160 in beer retail not including all of those were either membership or fire F5 finger related beers.

 

Xul bananarama for Chemtrail mix. Am I close on this one fellas?

 

Where type of valuations are both Michters 10 trading at? Trying to figure out a reasonable offer.