Trade Value Thread (Q1 2021)

Thanks for the info and definitely helpful! Appreciate it!

 

Hey Team. I was offered an Old Carter b6 for WFP SP

thinking the WFP SP holds slightly higher value? Let me know if that’s wrong or if it’s fair for both sides.

 

Curious if anyone has traded or traded for a De Struise Double Black recently. I have no idea what these go for, but I think the initial cost per bottle was pretty high during the last release (2015? 70 Euros or so). I have some vintage lambic for trade, but that might pose a Venn diagram issue. Any ideas? Thanks.

 

Since I missed it this morning, would a Daughters of the Light land an Anabasis b5?

 

Hey guys. I have the new batch of anabasis and thinking of trading it. Would that work 1:1 for a Maman?

What about db assassin or shadow raptor? I assume I would need a plus for either of them but just was not sure how big of a plus.

Cheers!

 

Maman should be no problem. DB Assassin you're mayyyybe halfway there. Not sure about shadow raptor.

 

I'm thinking of posting an ISO for No Rules but have no idea if it should go in the Limited, $4$ or Local forum and what type of FL beer it would take to close.

Where is trade value on No Rules compared to Cigar City Marshal Zhukov's, Hunahpu's, Hidden Springs DB Black Aggie or something from AC?

 

Anyone know approximate value of the new Narrow Gauge BA PB & Stout set? Would Maman get all 4? 3?

 

I haven’t seen a lot of these move. Saw a couple sets go for random StL bottles early on as well as DBBCS 1:4 and recently saw a set go for Oude fermier v19. I just agreed to a trade for monkish m9.1 + Anna v + gin bro for one of my sets. Doesn’t hurt to try the maman 1:4, but in the end I think you’ll need to add a plus.

 

Anybody know how Maman 2020 compares to Minutiae value-wise?

 

Yeah I'd think MZ should add some local cans, Huna 1:1, DB Black Aggie would demand multiple No Rules or something of similar value, up to 1:3.

 

Great feedback, thanks!

 

Daughters this and Daughters that...

 

Ok, thanks. I'll see if I can find someone to proxy for me.

 

Perrin is great! Reminds me of good times in the summer!

 

Any ideas on value for Cantillon Aronia? Would it go 1:1 with Blessed or maybe something else from Anchorage like Tired But Wired or Wendigo? I’m assuming I’d be going intl.

 

Sure, why not? I mean they’re both tasty beers I think that sounds fair to me.

 

Aronia is kind of in a strange place at the moment. Only 400 bottles sold to the public that I know of, which in the world of Cantillon should make it a mega whale, but given the mixed reviews there are a handful of people looking to offload it. Based on the offers I’ve seen, I suppose Blessed would be worth a shot in an international trade but is still probably short IMO. The other Anchorage would be even less likely (Wendigo has sat on shelves near me for 6 months).

For reference, I see someone currently asking for 3x St Lamvinus for their Aronia and that seems quite reasonable to me.