Better beer at Pigeon Hill by a slight mark. Better food, vibe and live tunes at Unruly. Beer is still solid at Unruly. Skip em both and hit Odd Side instead, only a 25min drive.
I will be within walking distance of Odd Side earlier in the week. So I will be there then. As of right now Unruly looks like the winner simply because they are open an hour till 11 and Pigeon is open till 10. I most likely won't be there till 9 so I don't want to be rushed.
If Pigeon Hill has their OCP stout (Oatmeal Cream Pie) on tap, and it looks like they do right now https://www.facebook.com/PigeonHillBrew/photos/a.367114153419480.1073741826.235859623211601/673302379467321/?type=1&theater, then Pigeon Hill should be your choice.
I really like Pigeon Hill. OCP is cool as stated, little gimmicky, but their renegade white DIPA is really nice. Unruly is a pretty cool place, does more styles, but I don't think they execute them as well. Unruly does serve pizza and there's also a pizza place right across the hall from Pigeon Hill that you can take into their tasting room.
