Hop City, hands down the best shop in town. Great bottle selection, growler fills, and you can drink a pint while you shop. http://www.beeradvocate.com/beer/profile/29996/?view=ratings
Agreed. I'd also throw out Highland Package if you have time for more than one stop. If you want pizza with a nice tap selection, I'd recommend Slice Pizza. It's not far from Hop City or Highland Package.