Favorite Pumpkin Beers?

No favorite here! This is the one style that I just don't like. I guess that just leaves more for those that do like it!

 

Warlock for sure, Schlafly is up there as well

 

Good Gourd / GG Almighty
Big shout out to Selinsgrove Pumpkin Ale on nitro. It is my favorite behind the two above.

I am having a pumpkin tasting at my house including the following

GGA
Heirloom Pumpkin
Schlafly
Crown Valley Imperial Pumpkin Smash
Trick or Treat
Maple Mistress
2012 Pumpkinator
Headless Heron
Fall Saints
Ignus Fatus (probably infected)
Seasonal Creep
Caution Contains Real Pimpkins
PumKyn - Avery
Some Tequilla BA Pumpkin Ale whose name I forget
Warlock
Braaaiins
Pumpkin Pie Lust
Baked Pumpkin Ale - Lancaster Brewing Company

And a few others I can't remember...........

 

I've rated 24 thus far. Here's my top 5:
1)Avery Pump[KY]n
2)Avery Rumpkin
3)Dogfish Head Punkin
4)Epic Fermentation Without Representation
5)Schlafly Pumpkin Ale

 

A new one to add to your 'try' list - Ballast Point's Pumpkin down, their Scottish ale with pumpkin added. Quite tasty.
http://www.beeradvocate.com/beer/profile/199/104076/

 

I still like Avery Rumpkin.

Tried 2 Road's - Road's Mary's Baby this weekend. Pretty good, but I think I liked the name better than the beer.

 

just tried ST pumking pretty darn tasty although too sweet to drink in quantity
also like dogfish punkin ale

 

Dogfish Head Punkin has been consistently excellent over the years.

Cheers!

 

1. My neighbor's homebrew pumpkin beer (won a few homebrew competition medals even)
2. Good Gourd (Cigar City)
3. Pumpkick (New Belgium)

 

ST's Warlock is my favorite 'darker' pumpkin beer and I've enjoyed Pumking in the past, even though I know all too well of the love it/hate it that most people have for it. New Holland's Ichabod has always been my favorite in the more normal class with an honorable mention for DFH Punkin.

Looking forward to doing an annual pumpkin beer tasting to see how my palate has changed, but thus far this year I've been impressed with Griffin Claw's Screamin' Pumpkin (looking forward to getting my hands on some that has been barrel-aged this year).

 

In case I didn't chime in on this thread below
http://www.beeradvocate.com/community/threads/best-pumpkin-beers.323307/

1)Schlafly
2) Schlafly
3) Whole Hog
4) Crown Valley Imperial Smash
5)Weyerbacher

 

Of all time...

Heirloom Pumpkin Barleywine, aged in brandy barrels, from Almanac - everything I ever wanted in a pumpkin ale - complex, decadent, boozy, a hint of vegetal character, plenty of autumnal sugars and spice... 12% abv...

Followed-up by...
Avery's Pump[KY]n and Heavy Seas The Greater Pumpkin - both bourbon barrel aged, sweet and boozy with pumpkin and spice - big and lush...
Rum Barrel Pumking and Avery's Rumpkin were similar, but aged in rums barrels which brought a pineapple-like tropical fruit character into the mix, which I really liked...

Uinta had a Oak Jacked Imperial Pumpkin ale (oak aged, 'natch) that I really liked, too.

These big boys aside, I have gotten Pumking, Smashed Pumpkin, and Punkin' every year for the past 4 or 5, and I'm likely to do the same this year...

 

New Holland's Ichabod is probably my favorite, ignoring more extreme (e.g., "imperial") beers. I also like DFH which, BTW, ages well, and several others including Terrapin. I must admit I too often find over-spiced "pumpkin" beers.

 

schlafly, smells like it taste

 

Neshaminy Creek Bourbon Barrel Punkless Dunkel and Avery PumpKYn

 

Not to dwell or reiterate the suggestions above, but there's a tasty Midnight Sun T.R.E.A.T.

 

Jolly Pumpkin La Parcela
Almanac Dark Pumpkin Sour
Southern Tier Warlock

 

2013 BBA Smashed Pumpkin

 

Just bought Elysian Punkaccino at Target the other day. $3.99 for a bomber! Awesome deal and very flavorful!

 

Favorite is probably Cape Ann's Fisherman's Pumpkin Stout. Favorite new pumpkin beer so far this year is Schlafly's Pumpkin.