Pumpkin beer recommendations?

Southern Tier's Pumpkin is still the remaining champion in my book (though I did find it on draft this year and was not a fan...almost as if the pint glass got an extra hit of the "spices" and lingered well after the final sip).

New Holland's Ichabod is my close second and is a bit less "pumpkin-y" in my opinion.

 

Might as well update my running list since this thread keeps on going. Really interesting to see the variety of opinions going on and where people tend to agree and disagree the most. Ordering is roughly in order of preference but there are many ties, especially in the middle. First four are no doubts for next year.

-Upper Tier-
Cisco Pumple Drumkin - Great blend of hopiness and pumpkin spices
Cape Ann Fisherman's Imperial Pumpkin Stout - Good stout with pumpkin notes
Ithaca Country Pumpkin - Really liked the sweet maltiness going on
Cambridge Brewing Co. The Great Pumpkin Ale - Good drinking experience. Gets the pumpkin just right.
Weyerbacher Imperial Pumpkin - Spices really blended well in this one. Drinks great for 8% just with it was slightly less carbed.
Heavy Seas The GeatER Pumpkin - I liked the creamyness and at 10% you can still feel like you're drinking.

-Middle Tier-
Two Roads Roadsmary's Baby - Just good drinking.
Sam Adams Pumpkin Harvest - Solid with moderate spice and sweetness. Readily available to pick up for parties.
Harpoon UFO Pumpkin - Another solid option readily available. Easy drinking too.
Dogfish Head Punk'n - Not bad. Bit more of a punch than the others in here.
Anderson Valley Fall Hornin' - Decent but a little too sweet and vanilla tasting to rank higher.
Long Trail Pumpkin Ale - Not a bad pumpkin beer, but I rate it behind the SA and Harpoon offerings.

-Misses-
Wasatch Pumpkin Ale - Not that great an ale base with no finish to the spices it starts with. Not for me.
Southern Tier Pumpking - I hated Pumking this year and it sort of surprised me. Unbalanced spices and way too buttery. Won't do that again with so many other options.
Southern Tier Warlock - See Pumpking. Too much spice and butter for me. Maybe if it was a bit thicker....

 

http://www.beeradvocate.com/beer/profile/14/6523/

brewed down the street from me and is in my opinion one of the best out there

 

I just found a Saint Arnold Pumpkinator, I'm hoping it will be my favorite. It sounds like something I would enjoy.
I'm not a big fan of pumpkin beers, but I loved Alpine's 2014 Ichabod. Smells and tastes like you're carving a pumpkin.
Avery's Rumpkin is more of a spirit than a beer, and I like it. I have an Avery Pump[KY]n, which I'm a little afraid to open, I think age will do it a favor. That's pretty much all I will do for the Pumpkin Season.
I hate the traditional pumpkin beer that I would describe as Dogfish Head Punkin and Coronado Punk'in Drublic, they always are too sweet for me. But I wouldn't pass on trying Pumking...

 

#1) Pumpkinator
#2) Good Goord
#3) Almanac Heirloom Pumpkin

 

Had these two for the first time this season, solid brews:

Local Fields Gourdgeous - Hangar 24 Brewery - Rich porter
Witch's Hair Pumpkin Ale - Twisted Manzanita Ales - Liquid Pumpkin Pie

Hangar 24 has been a local fav of mine for years, they've blown up with most bombers available in grocery stores (if you live in California). Gourdgeous might be tough to track down..

 

Top 5 for me in no specific order:

Pumpkinator
Good Gourd Almighty
Schlafly Pumpkin
Stevens Point Whole Hog Pumpkin Ale
Avery PumpKYn

 

Roudabout Jacked Up O Lantern Stout and Warlock

 

The Top pumpkin beers I've had would be (in no order)

Rumpkin ( with a year on it)
Fermentation without Representation
Dark o' The Moon
Heirloom Pumpkin Barleywine
Schlafly Pumpkin Ale